![]() |
||||||||||||||||
NOTE: Make sure you 'enable images' to see this e-bulletin properly. WHAT IS THIS? You are receiving this e-bulletin because you are subscribed to the CMU Daily. Unsubscribe information is given at the bottom of this e-bulletin. | ||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||||||||
IMPALA RETURN TO COURT OVER SONYBMG MERGER As much previously reported, IMPALA surprised many, and maybe even themselves, when, in 2006, they successfully appealed, through the European Courts Of Justice, the original 2004 decision made by the Commission's competition authority which allowed the merger of Sony Music and BMG. The ECJ agreed with the indie label trade body that the Commission's competition people had not sufficiently investigated the impact the further consolidation of the major labels would have on the wider record and music industry. The ECJ themselves don't have the authority to undo the merger, merely to set aside the Commission's ruling on procedural grounds. Having done just that, the Commission's competition team re-reviewed the Sony BMG merger proposition anew - even though the merged SonyBMG had, by this time, been in existence for two years. Having undertaken what they called a more thorough investigation, the Commission announced last Autumn that they were again going to give the merger the green light. Now, nearly four years on from the merger, IMPALA have returned to the ECJ to appeal that second Commission ruling on the matter, arguing that those damn competition officials only went and bungled the second investigation too. The trade body's main point isn't so much that the merger shouldn't have been given the go ahead at all, but that it should have been conditional - with the major being forced to provide 'remedies' to the wider record industry. Concentrating on the need for remedies is pragmatic on the part of IMPALA. Realistically, four years on, even if European officials decided that, after all, the 2004 merger should never have happened, it would be hard to return SonyBMG back to its constituent parts of Sony Music and BMG, especially if Bertelsmann is no longer even a partner in the business by the time that ruling is made. However, it would be practical to force the major to provide remedies to the independent sector, especially if those were financial rather than involving large scale sell offs of parts of its label operations or catalogue. As previously reported, when there were plans afoot for Warner and EMI to merge early last year IMPALA reached an agreement with Warner chief Edgar Bronfmann Jr which would have seen the major provide undefined remedies to the indie sector to win their approval of the merger. Of course, said merger, and said remedies, never materialised after Guy Hands' Terra Firma bought EMI - though not before the Warner/IMPALA deal had caused some controversy in the indie community, with some key indies, most prominently Ministry Of Sound, disagreeing with the deal. I've no idea what the timescale is for the ECJ to consider IMPALA's latest appeal. But I do know what IMPALA co-President and !K7 Records chief Horst Weidenmueller thinks. He told CMU yesterday: "A merger such as this with no remedies has repercussions for thousands of artists and small businesses across Europe. IMPALA's primary issue is the dysfunctioning of the music market. Online is the key example here and the EC should look more closely at how the majors are controlling the roll-out of this market". IMPALA Executive Chair Helen Smith added: "There is a huge contradiction here. Politically the EC is light years ahead of where it was when it first authorised the SonyBMG merger. But, we still seem to be some way off relying on the regulators to guarantee an open and competitive market, so we had no choice but to appeal. At the same time we welcome the new political agenda at EC level and are ready to work on concrete market access measures to empower thousands of SME music operators and their artists, as set out in IMPALA's Action Plan adopted in March". -------------------------------------------------- IS FORMER ZOMBA CHIEF BIDDING FOR SONYBMG STAKE? Calder's Zomba company, which operated the Jive label, was one of the US pop industry's hottest properties for a while, having, as it did, Britney Spears, Backstreet Boys and Nsync on its rosters just when those artists were at their very peak. BMG bought Zomba off Calder for over $3 billion in 2002, considerably more than the $1.5 billion Bertelsmann are now asking for their half of SonyBMG. Calder has stayed away from the music business since his big Bertelsmann pay off, but there are rumours that he is planning a come back, and is prepared to give $1.2 billion back to Bertelsmann in return for their SonyBMG share, which is a pretty good deal for him - even though neither Bertelsmann nor SonyBMG now own the Zomba publishing catalogue that was part of the 2002 deal, half of SonyBMG's vast recordings catalogue and label operations for less than half what he got for Zomba seems like a bit of a bargain. Of course, as we said, Sony Corp are also reportedly negotiating to buy Bertelsmann's 50% of SonyBMG, and they [a] have a first option to buy until next year under the 2004 merger agreement and [b] are reportedly willing to offer more cash than Calder, so even if the Zomba man is, as reported, interested, he is probably the less likely bidder to win Bertelsmann's SonyBMG stake. Still, given all the insecurities that exist in financial circles regarding the record industry, it might be easier for billionaire Calder to mount a successful bid than for Sony Corp to persuade its shareholders that complete ownership of SonyBMG is worth one and half billion dollars of their money. -------------------------------------------------- WINEHOUSE TAKEN TO HOSPITAL AFTER FAINTING -------------------------------------------------- SPEARS JUDGED NOT AT FAULT IN PAPARAZZO CASE -------------------------------------------------- COLDPLAY REFUTE MELODY COPY CLAIMS The frontman of a band called Creaky Boards, one Andrew Hoepfner, has claimed in a posting on the net that Coldplay's Chris Martin came to one of his gigs last year, and that now they have heard the song 'Viva La Vida' off the British band's new long player and found it uses the melody from one of their songs. Hoepfner writes: "We were flattered when we thought we saw Chris Martin in the crowd that night. He seemed pretty into it. Maybe too into it". But Coldplay's people have refuted those claims, saying that Martin had written the title track to his band's new album by March last year, before he had ever come across Creaky Boards. So, that's that then. -------------------------------------------------- STONES DENY LIVE NATION RECORD DEAL The Stones are currently looking for a new record deal having completed their recording commitments to EMI. With "every artist in the world quitting Guy Hands' EMI" a popular story in the press just now, it has been widely reported that Jagger et al would look elsewhere for their next record deal. Universal Music, who released the soundtrack to the recent Martin Scorsese directed Stones concert film, are a favourite to sign the aging rockers, though with Live Nation known to be keen to sign multi-dimensional deals with more iconic artists - similar to those done with Madonna and Jay-Z, both of which include recordings - rumours of a Stones/Live Nation deal have been rife. The fact that the Live Nation Artists division that is handling the Madonna and Jay-Z deals is run by Michael Cohl, long time Stones tour promoter, have only added to those rumours. But after the Observer reported on Sunday that a Live Nation deal involving recordings was about to be signed, LD Publicity's Bernard Doherty issued a statement on the band's behalf yesterday, telling reporters, simply: "We are not in talks with Live Nation in connection with any record deal". So, take note people. -------------------------------------------------- DUFFY WINS SONG OF THE YEAR AT MOJO HONOURS LIST Coming up, the winners list in full, but first Mojo Editor In Chief Phil Alexander on the winners of his magazine's Icon Award, those there Sex Pistols: "As punk's standard-bearers, the Sex Pistols truly re-defined modern music in the space of one solitary album. Who else has managed that? They also influenced every aspect of popular culture - from fashion to the media, film and literature and on to the music industry itself. They remain totems for rebellion in a manner that is totally unique and which we are proud to salute with this award". The public voted awards... The Mojo writer voted awards... -------------------------------------------------- SILVERCHAIR MAN SCORES SONGWRITER OF THE YEAR HAT TRICK AT AUSSIE SONGWRITER AWARDS -------------------------------------------------- NEW SEX PISTOLS ALBUM? -------------------------------------------------- LINKIN MAN DENIES VELVET REVOLVER RUMOURS Anyway, Bennington insists that the rumours have come from a misunderstanding. "I'm friends with all the guys in Velvet Revolver and have played with all of them before. I'm friends with Scott too," he said. "I think the rumour that I was going to join Velvet Revolver started because Slash asked me if I'd come play a show with them in Vegas right around the time that Scott left the band. Timing-wise, it didn't work out for me, though. Maybe people assumed that invitation meant I was joining the band". It's not because he wouldn't want to, however. He continued: "If I wasn't in Linkin Park any more and I didn't know Scott, though, I'd say yes. Who wouldn't? The music is great and it would be a really cool opportunity". -------------------------------------------------- NE-YO IS CONNERY FAN -------------------------------------------------- METALLICA ALBUM RUMOUR -------------------------------------------------- NEW RITON PROJECT A LITTLE BIT KRAUTROCK -------------------------------------------------- SPEARS' PUSSYCAT CAMEO CUT -------------------------------------------------- BONHAM JUNIOR ON ZEP APPEARANCE He told Musician magazine: "It was like the penalty shoot-out at the World Cup, but you're taking everyone. I had to shoot 16 times and get the goal every time. We all arrived separately and didn't communicate with each other until ten minutes before we went on. At that point I don't know what I was feeling. I was breathing deeply trying to keep calm. I knew I could do the gig, but could I do it when it counted?" He adds that he's eager for another reunion (even though that's looking unlikely at present). "It's hard to be in this situation where it was so good and now I'm left in limbo about what's going to happen next", he said. "I'm happy with what happened and if I ask for me it's me being greedy". -------------------------------------------------- SPECIAL CONCERT PLANNED FOR OLYMPIC HANDOVER The concert will include music and dance, the latter coming from the Royal Opera House, CanDoCo and those Into The Hoods Zoo Nation break dancing types. The bands set to play are being kept a secret, for reasons for which I'm not quite sure. The whole thing will finale with an artistic representation of what the Olympics are all about - a bunch of idiots will set fire to twenty billion pounds. No, only joking. Athletes from every sport, from across the world, from all cultures, from all backgrounds, from every society, will come together, hold hands, and then set fire to twenty billion pounds. No, not really. It will probably end with George Sampson break dancing or Leona Lewis warbling or something like that. Given the tabloid reports this morning that Simon Cowell has hired three former SAS soldiers to provide security for fourteen year old 'Britain's Got Talent' winner Sampson, who is apparently getting mobbed wherever he goes, if he is involved in the open air Olympics party this August (and he might as well be, it'll probably rain) perhaps the Chinese could send in some of those jump suited thugs to handle the security arrangements. -------------------------------------------------- LIVERPOOL MOST MUSICAL CITY Liverpool was declared most musical city by that previously reported Arts Council organised Most Musical City initiative. As a result of Liverpool's victory, Merseyside based unsigned band The Affection have won a slot at this year's End Of The Road festival in Dorset. While we're talking about Liverpool's musical heritage, can I mention that my Mum went to visit the childhood homes of Lennon and McCartney this weekend - now both owned by the National Trust - and she said they're brilliant? I can't remember what the rules are regarding assigning the 'CMU favourite' status to music based heritage attractions, but consider it assigned to that. And have I ever mentioned said Mum sat behind Cynthia Lennon at primary school? Not that I'm trying to up my Liverpudlian credentials to appear more musical or anything. --------------------------------------------------
US MUSICIANS UNION SUE OVER AMERICAN IDOL RERUNS The dispute centres on 'American Idol Rewind', a repeat of the main pop reality programme that airs on various US TV networks after the main series and competition is done and dusted. I think the problem is that, in order to avoid having to pay the musicians whose music appeared on the original version of the show a second fee based on a union agreement (75% of the original fee and a pension fund contribution), producers had the music rerecorded by new musicians under a new agreement more favourable to the TV makers. The union says they weren't informed of this until after the fact, and that the second agreement violated another collective bargaining agreement. I think I'm right in saying the lawsuit relates specifically to the second series of 'American Idol'. The union is suing in a bid to have the musicians whose music appeared on the main 'American Idol' series paid a fee for the repeat series, even though their music didn't actually appear on it. They are also looking for damages and legal fees, oh, and an injunction to stop TV producers switching music on reruns to avoid royalty payments again in the future. -------------------------------------------------- MORE CONSOLIDATION EXPECTED IN US BOOKING AGENCY SECTOR Some smaller booking agents in the US - who have traditionally survived by specialising in a niche area and/or on the back of a handful of bankable higher profile clients - say that because live revenues are increasingly important to bands and their managers, and because more and more artists are looking for agents who can represent them in the profitable TV, media, literary and brand partnership sectors as well as in the booking of gigs and tours, it is harder for them to hang on to the bigger artists on which they depend for their financial security. The solution for many is to merge with one of the bigger agencies, so they can offer their artists the combined skills and contacts of the bigger company. The article follows the acquisition of Californian based independent the Kork Agency by the big Agency Group. It's founder, Christian Bernhardt, tells the trade mag: "With the record companies becoming more obsolete, it's important [for artists] to have a bigger company [in the live sector] that can go into areas a smaller company can't go into. I think [agency mergers are] going to become a trend". Agency Group boss Neil Warnock adds: "You will see this company make other acquisitions over the next period of time. You either get acquired or you acquire". -------------------------------------------------- MORE ON THE BMR YOUTH SURVEY As previously reported, the survey of 14-24 year olds revealed that the average kid of the street has over 800 illegally download tracks on their MP3 player, and has no problem sharing their digital music collections with others. Then again, it wasn't all doom and gloom in the stats. For starters, the survey said that the average respondent had 1770 tracks on their iPod, over half of which were pirated. While that means over 800 were illegally downloaded, it also means that 800 odd had been paid for, either as legit downloads or ripped off CD, which sounds a pretty good stat to me. While the average teenager when I was that age wouldn't have owned 1770 tracks, probably more than half their record collection had been taped off the radio or off friends, so on percentage terms perhaps things aren't that much worse than before. Perhaps. But more importantly, the respondents also said they were still interested in buying CDs for their favourite artists, and that they (well, 80% of them) would be willing to pay to use a good legit P2P file sharing service. Whether said respondents would stand by that commitment once such a service is available remains to be seen, but it is good news for that legit P2P service that is about to launch, Qtrax, and the labels and publishers participating in it. Anyway, however you interpret the specifics, the survey definitely reaffirms that the music market has changed dramatically in recent years, and that the music business has to continue to adapt to survive long term. Sharkey says this: "The music industry should draw great optimism from this groundbreaking survey. First and foremost, it is quite clear that this young and tech-savvy demographic is as crazy about and engaged with music as any previous generation. Contrary to popular belief, they are also prepared to pay for it too. But only if offered the services they want. That message comes through loud and clear". He continued: "These responses also pull no punches in highlighting how dramatically music consumption has changed, and continues to change; certainly in the case of copying, sharing and recommendation. Technology has greatly increased the value of these activities - but it is clear that the financial gains are not necessarily feeding back to the creators: artists, composers and songwriters. How the music industry repositions itself here, and builds new mutually-beneficial commercial partnerships with technology providers remains the key challenge ahead". David Bahanovich, Head of Music and Entertainment Industry Management Programme at University of Hertfordshire, adds: "As we witness the seismic changes to the music industry's landscape, timely and targeted research is not only welcome, but is of critical importance. Our recent collaboration with BMR has proven very fruitful and our findings will be of great interest to both industry and government. We are committed to helping the industry find solutions through groundbreaking research, and this is only the first of a series of projects with BMR addressing some of the key issues confronting our industry during this unprecedented time of change". -------------------------------------------------- MEDIANET TO POWER EXPANDED TESCO DOWNLOAD STORE The supermarket giant announced it would step up its online entertainment offer earlier this year, expanding its film, TV programme and game download offer, and moving its music service into the DRM-free iPod compatible MP3 domain. MediaNet, which changed its name a while back as it diversified into digital content other than music, will power that expanded Tesco service. Tesco's Commercial Director, Graham Harris, told reporters: "MediaNet's fully customised service, comprehensive media library as well as their knowledge and experience have helped us to achieve our goals". MediaNet chief Alan McGlade added: "Our aim is to help Tesco Digital deliver the right mix of content and ease of use for their customer base". -------------------------------------------------- SONY/ATV TO OFFER EUROPE-WIDE DIGITAL LICENCE THROUGH GEMA As previously reported, various publishers have been working with various collecting societies across Europe to deliver cross-Europe licencing, responding to the demands of both the digital music providers, who can't be bothered doing separate publishing royalty deals for ever territory they operate in, and also from European Union competition officials who want national collecting societies to operate in each other's territories in order to stop any one society having a monopoly over royalties in their home country. Announcing that the pan-European licensing framework would launch next month through the GEMA partnership, Sony/ATV chief Marty Bandier said in a statement: "Our goal is to help speed the development of new online and mobile services across Europe - ensuring that the needs of consumers, regardless of where they may live, will have greater access to our music, sooner. And as these services become durable, legitimate businesses, they will benefit our writers and composers, as well". GEMA boss Harald Heker added: "The cooperation with Sony/ATV Music Publishing is a great enhancement for GEMA, as it enables us to continue to license the Anglo-American repertoire further". EMI Music Publishing announced a similar pan-European digital licensing system with GEMA and UK collecting society MCPS-PRS earlier this year. -------------------------------------------------- FCC BOSS GIVES BACKING TO SIRIUS XM MERGER As previously reported, Sirius and XM have been trying to merge for ages. The merger will give them a monopoly in the US satellite radio space, hence the FCC concerns, but the two firms argue that they compete with terrestrial broadcasters and online music services, so a merged Sirius XM will not be too dominant. Martin said in a statement yesterday: "As I have indicated before, this is an unusual situation. I am recommending that with the voluntary commitments they've offered, on balance, this transaction would be in the public interest". Recent reports suggested that the FCC would approve the merger but with conditions, with some saying said conditions would make the merger unpalatable for Sirius and XM. But it seems the two satellite radio firms have come forward with their own concessions - the voluntary commitments referred to by Martin - in order to sweeten the deal for those with monopoly concerns. According to reports in the US press those voluntary commitments include price rise constraints, the introduction of economy line packages, the introduction of an open standard for radio set manufacture, a new a la carte service to complement current subscription based packages, and a commitment to public interest programming. Following Martin's comments a spokesman for the FCC said: "We have no indication on how the votes will go and whether this will be approved as proposed. This proposal will start the discussion on what the transaction will look like if approved". -------------------------------------------------- LINLEY GETS HEAT EDITOR JOB -------------------------------------------------- SUGABABES DON'T THINK CHERYL IS A GOOD X FACTOR JUDGE REPLACEMENT Fellow Babe Amelle Berrabah added: "Yeah, Boy George has generations more on her. Not that Cheryl hasn't got any experience, but someone who has been going for as long as he has should have been given a chance". I'm not sure Boy George was ever considered was he? And I suppose Cole has been through the whole 'win a reality show, then get thrown in a the deep end with high expectations and a presumption you'll fail' thing, so perhaps she is qualified to take over from Sharon Osbourne on the ITV show. -------------------------------------------------- WEST BOOED AT BONNAROO -------------------------------------------------- MADDEN BORED BY WEDDING CLAIMS Explaining his reasons for the post, he wrote: "I feel really stupid even posting this, but I've been getting calls and texts from my family all week asking me why they weren't invited to my wedding. I guess the only answer I could give them was that I didn't know we were having one. Sooooo if you were pissed at me for not inviting you or even telling you, don't blame me, there's nothing to worry about". -------------------------------------------------- MYERS ON TIMBERLAKE'S 'PACKAGE' Hilarious. |
||||||||||||||||
SUBSCRIPTIONS>> CMU Daily is a free daily e-bulletin for people working in the music industry and music media, delivered direct to your PC each morning. If you want to stop receiving this e-bulletin click the 'unsubscribe' button below and follow the instructions. If any of your colleagues want to receive the CMU Daily tell them to email their name, company, job title and email to [email protected]. If you would like to recieve the CMU Daily as a text email, send a blank email from the email address you are registered at to [email protected]. MEDIA PEOPLE>> If you want to run stories from the CMU Daily in your media, please credit it to UnLimited/CMU with a link to www.cmumusicnetwork.co.uk - thanks! If you are looking for an independent quote on anything to do with the music business, or you need someone to come on your TV or radio show and talk music business, then we can help. There's nothing we don't know about. Email requests to [email protected].uk or call 020 7099 9050. CMU is published by and (c) UnLimited Media - www.unlimitedmedia.co.uk Send news stories to [email protected]. If we don't respond directly, we do apologise, only we get sent hundreds of emails a day and don't have time to respond to every one of them. However we do check every email sent to the musicnews email address, and do pull out stories that we feel are relevant to our readers. Send CDs for review to CMU, UnLimited Media, 221-222 Shoreditch High Street, London, E1 6PJ. |
||||||||||||||||