Jul 17, 2009 • 2 min read

AIM call for MCPS to share the risk in Pinnacle-style collapses

AIM chief Alison Wenham has called on MCPS to waive royalties on CDs labels were never paid for after the Pinnacle distributor collapse.

Talking of record label v MCPS disputes, the boss of the Association Of Independent Music, Alison Wenham, this week raised another grievance with the mechanical rights body at the AGM of the indie label trade body. Wenham isn't happy with MCPS reserving the right to collect mechanical royalties on CDs that have been sold but which the label itself has not been paid for.

This is a big issue in the indie sector right now because of the collapse late last year of independent distributor Pinnacle. Many indie labels were owed money by the distributor for stock that had already been sold, money they are now unlikely to see. Sort of adding insult to injury, because of the technicalities of an MCPS licence, the indies who won't now receive payment for stock caught up in the Pinnacle collapse will still receive a bill from the collecting society for the publishing royalties. The society has agreed to allow any labels who owe royalties on such stock to pay what they owe in phased instalments. But most affected labels aren't that thrilled about having to pay the royalties at all.

Speaking at the AIM AGM, Wenham compared CDs caught up in the Pinnacle collapse with stock that is returned to the label unsold, on which MCPS royalties would not be due. She said: "In the 1991 copyright tribunal, the judge Robin Jacob said 'royalties should be paid on net sales, records distributed but then returned unsold should ideally not carry any royalty'. If the judge recommended a solution for goods sold and subsequently returned, he would surely have recommended that goods for which the labels do not receive any payment at all should also be exempt from royalties. It surely is a better solution for us all to recognise the sense in giving the labels a break on this exceptional catastrophe".

She continued: "I do understand and support PRS For Music's determination to protect the value of their rights, but surely not at the expense of sharing at least some of the risks of trading in this challenging environment".

It seems that so far MCPS hasn't been so willing to budge on this issue, despite surely knowing how gutting it must be for an indie label owner that has just written off potentially thousands because of Pinnacle's sudden demise to then be presented with an MCPS bill. Perhaps aware that in the current economic climate more Pinnacle style traumas may be on the horizon, Wenham indicated that she and her colleagues at the BPI might consider going to the Copyright Tribunal to amend MCPS licences so that royalties are not due on stock for which a label is not paid. Though, as always, she stressed that a visit to the Tribunal was not desirable, for the reasons we've already outlined.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy