Sep 6, 2005 • 2 min read

Australian courts tell Kazaa to stop the piracy

The Australian Federal Court has ordered Kazaa's owners Sharman to modify their software within two months to prevent copyright piracy, finding they encouraged users to infringe.

Well, the courts do seem to be ruling in favour of the good old music industry of late, which is nice. The latest court to rule in our favour is in Australia, where the Federal Court in Sydney has ruled that the makers of the P2P network Kazaa actively urged its users to breach copyright. Concluding that very long and much previously reported court battle between Kazaa owners Sharman and the Australian music industry, judges ordered the P2P company to modify its software to prevent further piracy. And I should think so too.

Coming just months after the US Supreme Court's landmark ruling against the owners of P2P network Grokster, the new ruling is being seen by the music industry as a sign that the courts are finally coming round to their opinion that companies that make file sharing software can be and should be held liable for the copyright violation their technology enables. Previously courts have been unhappy to make such judgements, keen to uphold the principle known in the US as the Betamax ruling, which said that if a technology has legitimate uses the makers of such technology cannot be held liable if consumers choose to use it for illegitimate purposes. Kazaa's owners used that principle as their defence in the Australian court case.

However, Federal Court Judge Murray Wilcox, hearing the case, did not, as such, reject that principle. He said that accusations that Kazaa's owners themselves were guilty of copyright violation were "overstated". Rather, the company was guilty of complacency - they knew their software was used for copyright theft but did nothing to combat it. In fact, through their own website, they implied that stealing the copyright of record labels and music publishers was a "cool" thing to do. Wilcox: "The more realistic claim is that the respondents authorised users to infringe the applicants' copyright in their sound recordings".

With that in mind Wilcox ordered Kazaa's owners to adapt their software, within two months, so that it safeguards against copyright piracy. That is a similar order to that placed on the original Napster several years back. The courts objected to Napster because there was a central database that tracked files being shared, and therefore the P2P network's owners could, and the courts ruled should, monitor file sharing to stop the illegal distribution of copyrighted material.

While it is not quite as easy for Kazaa to monitor the files being shared via their network (there being no central database), it has been said for some time that there are certain adaptations that could be made to their software that would limit the amount of copyrighted content shared. Whether Kazaa will want to introduce such adaptations remains to be seen - when the original Napster started to filter files being shared on its networks its subscribers quickly jumped ship, leaving the company with huge legal bills and a dwindling membership, leading, ultimately, to bankruptcy.

It was perhaps with that in mind, that John Kennedy of the International Federation Of The Phonographic Industry concluded that the ruling will have a global impact, despite the court's jurisdiction being limited to Australia. He told reporters yesterday: "Today's judgement shows that Kazaa, one of the biggest engines of copyright theft and the biggest brand in music piracy worldwide, is illegal. This is a milestone in the fight against internet piracy worldwide."

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy