BBC top man Mark Thompson has issued a strongly worded response to James Murdoch's attack on the Corporation. Son of Rupert used his big speech at the Edinburgh TV Festival last month to issue a stinging attack on the licence fee-funded broadcaster, accusing it of having ambitions far beyond those its public service remit should allow, and calling on government to cut the Corporation down to size.
The Murdoch regime, and therefore the family's UK papers, have always been anti-BBC, though it's true that many more commercial media chiefs have become increasingly critical of the Corporation in the last 18 months as they see BBC bosses lobby for an increase in the licence fee (and complain loudly when an increase is denied) even though pretty much every Corporation-owned channel is vastly better funded that their commercial rivals, even more so given the recent advertising recession.
But, buoyed by a Guardian poll last weekend that showed the majority of the British public support the BBC, DG Thompson has hit back in an internal memo. He told his employees yesterday: "It must have made uncomfortable reading for those critics who would like the world to believe that trust and pride in the BBC is getting weaker rather than stronger. We've seen a pretty relentless onslaught from the press over the summer, culminating in James Murdoch's MacTaggart Lecture. The most important thing to say about that lecture and about many of the recent attacks on the BBC is that they are desperately out of touch with what the audience themselves are telling us".
Despite the strong words, Thompson admitted that the BBC did have to reconsider its role and position given the big changes going on in the commercial media, but argued that the Corporation is already doing exactly that. Meanwhile the BBC boss used the memo to imply once again that he and his colleagues will fight any efforts by the government to allocate a portion (even a tiny portion) of the licence fee to commercial media players with public service obligations, most likely to include ITV and Channel 4.
Just to clear up any confusion, the BBC has been vastly overfunded for 20 years and bosses there focus exclusively on empire building and never on delivering better value for licence fee payers. But then every home-grown programme ever commissioned by the Murdoch controlled Sky has been shit. So we probably shouldn't pay too much attention to either side in this debate.