The government have released their report into the BBC's online activities - the Graf Report - and its findings means that five BBC websites will close immediately. The report said that certain parts of the BBC's online activities were not distinct enough from commercial competitors to justify licence fee funding. The sites picked for the immediate axe are The What's On events listings site, Fantasy Football, the Games portal, the Surfing portal and the Pure Soap site.
On a more long term view, the report recommends the BBC's online unit should prioritise news and information over entertainment, that two governors should be given specific responsibility for online, and that the Beeb should aim to ensure at least a quarter of its online content is produced by independents by the end of 2006.
The BBC's director of New Media and Technology, Ashley Highfield, confirmed the closure of the five BBC sites explaining that "their market impact might be greater than their public value". But he added: "Importantly, [the report] also says it cannot be proven that our online services have had a negative impact on the market and that it's unlikely that bbc.co.uk has eliminated effective competition across any large areas of online content."
Although welcoming the report Hugo Drayton of the British Internet Publisher's Alliance - who don't really like BBC online - called for tougher restrictions to be put on the Beeb's online arm: "We want a proper independent regulator, and a proper remit for BBC Interactive. Any new services being subjected to the same approvals process as radio or any other form of broadcasting."