Jun 21, 2005 • 1 min read

BPI face bad press over individual litigation stories

The BPI faces negative press over a lawsuit against Sylvia Price, whose teenage daughter allegedly shared over 1,400 tracks online, with a £4,000 fine at stake.

The UK music industry body, the BPI, might be about to face similar negative press to its US counterpart as some of its litigation against individual file sharers reaches its conclusion.

The papers are currently reporting on one Sylvia Price, who is being targeted with a lawsuit by the trade body for copyright violation committed by her teenage daughter Emily. The mother says she was unaware her daughter was illegally sharing music online (she had shared over 1400 tracks), while the daughter claims she didn't know she was doing anything wrong. Nevertheless, Mrs Price now faces a £4000 fine. The story is a good one for the tabloid media because Price claims she can't afford the fine and says that she has been told she now faces jail time. Those claims are dubious, but nevertheless the story portrays the BPI as the aggressors.

The BPI will point out how much time and energy they invested in promoting the issues around illegal file sharing before beginning legal action - much more than their colleagues at the Recording Industry Association Of America. And earlier this month they launched a new publicity campaign specifically targeted at parents who are at risk of being sued for the file sharing actions of their children. However the Association can expect a series of stories like that of Mrs Price to be appearing in the British press in the coming months.

Of course it is debatable whether such negative press really matters - the US media reported on slip ups by the RIAA which saw a 12 year old girl and a dead grandmother being sued, but consumers do not really make a link between the industry organisations and the record labels they represent, and even less with the artists on those labels' rosters, so the bad press is unlikely to effect record sales. The only possible bad side effect is that young people start to justify file sharing to themselves on the basis they are rebelling against what they see as overly oppressive conglomerates who are more interested in money than music.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy