The BPI yesterday stepped up its legal campaign against illegal downloading by launching civil proceedings against five people suspected of making large amounts of copyrighted music available via P2P networks without the copyright owner's permission.
The new stage of litigation follows those previous successful lawsuits to secure the identities of suspected filesharers off their ISPs. Since that legal action began some sixty people have reached an out of court settlement with the trade organisation regarding their past file sharing activities. However the five people now facing new legal proceedings have refused to comply.
Announcing the new litigation, BPI chairman Peter Jamieson told CMU: "Music fans are increasingly tuning into legal download sites for the choice, value and convenience they offer. But we cannot let illegal filesharers off the hook. They are undermining the legal services, they are damaging music and they are breaking the law."
BPI General Counsel Geoff Taylor added: "So far 60 UK internet users have settled legal claims against them for illegal filesharing, paying up to £6,500 in compensation. We have tried to agree fair settlements, but if people refuse to deal with the evidence against them, then the law must take its course. That's why we have had no choice but to take these five individuals to the High Court. We will be seeking an injunction and full damages for the losses they have caused, in addition to the considerable legal costs we are incurring as a result of their illegal activity."
It will be interesting to see what will now happen should any of these lawsuits get to court. The conclusion that sharing music online without the permission of the copyright holders is illegal is pretty damn sound given UK copyright law, but it is only when things like this are put to test in the courts that we get any clarity as to how judges will apply those laws. Presumably the five people who have refused to settle out of court have reasons to make such a refusal. Of course, they may be disputing the evidence that is being used to prove they shared music online, but it would be interesting to see how things turned out should any of them be disputing the law - ie disputing the assumption that uploading tracks to P2P networks is illegal.
Of course, if the BPI win these court cases the file sharers in dispute will actually do the trade organisation a favour. The real value of targeting individual file sharers in this way isn't really the relatively modest compensation they can be forced to pay - but rather the PR potential of heavy handed litigation, scaring other potential downloaders away from non-legit music source. The media will take much more interest in a successful legal fight in the high court than in any out of court settlement.