The Canadian courts really don't like the music industry. Having told the record labels they can't target illegal file sharers there with RIAA style litigation until there is a change in copyright law, now the Federal Court of Appeal has said the proposals to add copyright tax to MP3 players sold in Canada are illegal.
Canada, like a number of other countries, has long added an extra tax to CD-Rs and audio cassettes which is passed on to the royalty bodies to compensate them for the copying of their artists' music that the CDs/tapes allow. As MP3 players arguably replace CD-Rs and audio cassettes in the digital age the record industry were pushing for a similar tax to be added to the sale of iPods et al. However Justice Marc Noël said last week that the current copyright act does not allow this: "As desirable as bringing such devices within the ambit of [the Act] might seem, the authority for doing so still has to be found in the Act".
That ruling will provide further incentive to the Canadian Recording Industry Association to push for changes in the country's copyright legislation. However, revamping said legislation could well take some time, so the CRIA may take their case for an MP3 player tax to the country's Supreme Court in the meantime.