May 20, 2005 • 1 min read

Canadian download battle delayed but not dead

The CRIA failed to win the right to identify 29 suspected file sharers in Canada, but the appeal court corrected the lower court's reading of copyright law.

There were mixed fortunes for the Canadian music industry this week as the Canadian Recording Industry Association took their bid to sue individual file sharers to the country's Federal Court Of Appeals.

The Canadian courts have not been kind to the CRIA as they attempt to follow the Recording Industry Association Of America in issuing litigation against individuals suspected of illegally sharing copyrighted music online. Last year a Canadian court not only ruled that internet service providers did not have to hand over the identities of suspected file sharers, but judges went on to essentially say that sharing copyright content via P2P networks was not illegal in the eyes of Canadian law.

Appealing that decision, the CRIA did not win the right to find out the identities of the 29 suspected file sharers, but the courts did rule that the lower court's interpretation of copyright law was incorrect. Judges refused to force the ISPs to hand over the identities of the 29 suspects because they said they were not convinced by the evidence against the supposed copyright violators. However, they did set our a framework for how the labels would have to gather such evidence in order to convince the courts of violation, meaning that, while the CRIA are still some way from launching those lawsuits, there a lot further on than they were at the start of the latest court case.

This is good news because the industry organisation's attempts to persuade government to push through changes in Canada's copyright law to clarify the illegality of sharing copyrighted music online are proving both slow and frustrating.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy