Aug 9, 2005 • 1 min read

Canadian judges overrule iPod levy

The Supreme Court of Canada has declined to hear appeals for copyright levies on MP3 players, ordering existing levies refunded, which Apple Canada welcomed.

The Supreme Court Of Canada has refused to hear further arguments calling for additional copyright levies to be added to the sale of digital music players. That campaign has been led by the Canadian Private Copying Collective who want the kind of royalty levies charged on the sale of blank tapes and CDRs extended to MP3 players.

As previously discussed at length here in the CMU Daily, that tape/CDR levy, which operates in a number of countries, assumes that people use their tapes or CDRs to make additional copies of music they already own. The argument flows that content owners should get an additional royalty for that copy, therefore a levy is charged on the tape/CDR which is passed on to the royalty bodies. A similar system had been adopted in Canada for the sale of MP3 players, and the CPCC wanted that system formalized and extended by the Supreme Court.

But judges not only disagreed with the CPCC, they ordered an end of the existing levy systems, telling royalty bodies to refund any levies taken so far to customers via the relevant MP3 player manufacturers.

Needless to say, those manufacturers welcomed that ruling. A spokesman for Apple Canada said they would be looking to get back any levies charged on iPod sales so far, and would return that money to their Canadian customers as soon as possible. A spokesman told reporters: "Apple is pleased that the Supreme Court of Canada let stand a lower court ruling that blank media levies on iPods are invalid, and will shortly announce a claims process so consumers can request a refund for the levies they paid."

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy