Dec 9, 2009 • 2 min read

Canadian majors sued for six billion

The estate of Chet Baker is suing the Canadian Recording Industry Association and its major label members over unpaid mechanical royalties on compilation tracks.

Yeah, I'm sure bosses at the four major record companies would love it if their Canadian divisions suddenly had to hand over six billion in hard cash. It would be particularly galling if said damages were ordered as a result of a successful copyright infringement claim made against the majors in Canada, given the Canadian courts haven't been especially helpful in recent years when it's the labels themselves shouting "infringement" in litigation relating to P2P file-sharing.

Talk of six billion dollar damages stem from the news that the estate of late jazz man Chet Baker is pursuing a lawsuit against the Canadian Recording Industry Association and its major label members in relation to their failure to pay mechanical royalties, mainly relating to compilations. The lawsuit claims that major record companies in Canada frequently release compilations carrying recordings of songs
without securing the appropriate licence regarding the literary and musical copyrights that exist in said songs (ie in the lyrics and musical score).

Officially, the labels are assuming there will be no problem securing a mechanical licence for those songs, and are just putting off the paper work, and payment, until later, by plonking the name of the unlicensed track onto a "pending list". However, lawyers representing the Baker estate claim many label execs who follow this practice just hope no one in the songwriting or publishing sector will notice one of their songs has slipped through the net, meaning no royalty payment will ever have to be made.

The Baker clan claim that between the four majors some 300,000 unlicensed works that have appeared on compilation releases over the last three decades now appear on the industry's collective "pending list". They say some record label execs admit that amounts to about CAN$50 million in unpaid royalties. But, the plaintiffs argue, that's not even the half of it, because that figure ignores interest payments and the possibility of the court applying penalties.

Statutory penalties might, arguably, be applied if the court was to believe Clan Baker's claim that the "pending list" system is employed not for administrative convenience, but as a tactic to try and avoid paying any royalties. Canadian copyright law allows for statutory damages of CAN$20,000 per infringement. The Baker estate's legal team are requesting their lawsuit be considered a class action, meaning if they won the court's ruling would apply to all Canadian songwriters and publishers, and therefore all 300,000 unlicensed songs. Which is where you get the six billion Canadian dollars figure from.

Of course "six billion damages" makes a good headline, but even if the Baker estate was successful in this lawsuit, it is unlikely damages would be anywhere near that figure. For starters the application to have this lawsuit treated as a class action is pending. Plus, presumably a fair share of those 300,000 unlicensed songs are actually owned by one of the four major music publishers - who, of course, share ownership with the major labels being sued. Surely that would be taken into consideration. Though - as the big P2P cases in the US have demonstrated - when it comes to copyright infringement damages, common sense doesn't always prevail.

The Baker estate's lawsuit is actually over a year old. It's come to wider attention thanks to an article by internet law expert Michael Geist in the Toronto Star. He observes: "After years of claiming Canadian consumers disrespect copyright, the irony of having the recording industry face a massive lawsuit will not be lost on anyone, least of all the artists still waiting to be paid".

Interesting, Canadian mechanical rights collecting bodies - the Canadian Musical Reproduction Rights Agency and Society For Reproduction Rights of Authors, Composers and Publishers - were originally named as defendants in the lawsuit, but they have since reached a settlement with the Baker estate, and now the boss of the former has provided an affidavit in support of the case.

More on this when we get it.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy