Chris Evans yesterday lost his court case against former employer Virgin Radio. As previously reported at length, Evans was suing Virgin Radio's parent group, SMG, for £8.6m of share options he claimed they owed him after they sacked him in 2001. SMG said he had voided his claim on the options by breaking his contract on a number of occasions and that, in fact, he owed them damages for jeopardising the station in the week before his dismissal.
Mr Justice Lightman yesterday said that Evans had lost his claim because he had breached his contract more than once. In particular the time Evans took time off unannounced to fly to America to marry Billie Piper, and the occasion when he phoned in sick and was then photographed on a drinking binge.
Justice Lightman said: "Mr Evans is a talented radio performer. His distinctive appearance, spontaneity, inventiveness and irreverence are his trademarks. He is very experienced in matters of publicity. He knows how to play the media and obtain a good splash. He is given to extremes: moderation has no part to play. Drinking to excess is part of his lifestyle. He is a binge drinker. He told me with pride and no trace of embarrassment that more often than not he presented the show with a hangover. He has a reputation for laddish behaviour including drunkenness. Despite his confident front, he is very insecure in himself and as a consequence frequently (but not invariably) has recourse to any means (legitimate or otherwise) to avoid confrontation or unpleasant or unpalatable situations. To achieve what he wants without confrontation, he is manipulative and has resort to any means, fair or foul, to achieve his ends." With this in mind Lightman denied Evans his claim to share options and ruled that SMG would be entitled to damages, which would be decided upon in a later hearing.
A spokesman for a jubilant Virgin Radio said: "We were always confident that the court would support our position that Chris Evans repeatedly breached the terms of his contract. It was clear to everyone when Chris Evans walked out on us - that Virgin Radio was put in an impossible situation, and had no option but to take the action we took at the time. We are saddened that it has taken so long, and this needless court case, for it to be established that his actions were totally unacceptable."