Mar 26, 2009 • 2 min read

Claims of chaos at EMI

Fox News columnist Roger Friedman alleges that EMI is in chaos after Guy Hands and Terra Firma largely withdrew, with EMI Digital head Douglas Merrill leaving.

Fox News gossip man Roger Friedman, in the US, has alleged that equity firm Terra Firma and its top man Guy Hands have all but lost hope in their chances of turning round the fortunes of London-based major record company EMI, and have left the company in chaos. The previously reported departure of former Google chief Douglas Merrill is a result of and adds to that chaos, he implies.

Freidman makes the allegations in a piece about Dhani 'son of George' Harrison's recent and previously reported comments about the continued efforts to get the Beatles catalogue officially available online. As previously reported, Harrison Jr last week said that Beatles company Apple Corps knew that it was counter-productive not having the Fab Four's music available via legit music services like iTunes, but said the right deal to put the band's music online had yet to come along.

Whereas Paul McCartney previously suggested the issue was the usual squabbles between EMI and Apple Corps over the Beatles catalogue, Harrison suggested that the bigger issue was their belief the Fab Four's music was worth more than 99 cents (or 79 pence) per track but that Apple iTunes, still the biggest player in the legit download space of course, wouldn't budge on per-track price point (actually Apple have just confirmed that their previously promised variable pricing system will go live next month, but ignore that for the time being). He suggested that EMI and Apple Corps were now considering setting up their own download store where they can have more control over things like price.

Friedman says that one plan was to set up a Beatles store on EMI.com, the major's current efforts to have its own digital hub, which launched last year in a sort of beta mode, and which could become the record company's own streaming and a-la-carte download service. The problem, Friedman says, is that EMI.com was one of Hands/Terra Firma/Merrill's grand plans, and has therefore gone on the back burner as those parties cut off their direct involvement with the major.

Which is how he gets on to making these claims about EMI. He writes: "EMI is in turmoil. Guy Hands, who bought the company with his Terra Firma firm, has pretty much bailed on the deal and is gone from running the company. Terra Firma has written off its investment in EMI and, not knowing what to do or particularly caring, has left the former music giant in a muddle. The result is chaos, sources say, within the EMI hierarchy. Just recently, Douglas Merrill, the head of EMI Digital, left his post after less than a year".

Hands and Terra Firma would presumably point out that they took more of a backseat role in the running of EMI once they had a CEO in place in its recordings division - Elio Leoni-Sceti - and that they are now letting his management team, much of it new recruits, get on with the business of fixing the major record company. Still, Hands' recent move into an 'investor placator' role at Terra Firma following the substantial negative impact of the EMI purchase on the value of the equity firm's portfolio, and Merrill's somewhat sudden departure for the major, will only fuel gossip that all is not well at the all new EMI.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy