Apr 13, 2005 • 2 min read

Concerns over revamped UK music charts

Independent label figures warn that the combined CD and download chart could be open to buy-back, with Chart Director Omar Maskatiya saying hyping will be policed.

Don't you just hate the music charts and everyone involved in making them? No? Well, we think the music charts are just ace, but it seems to be the fashion to knock them at the moment - well, to knock the incoming combined CD / download sales singles chart anyway. The planned singles chart revamp came in for some new criticism yesterday.

As previously reported, key players in the UK independent sector have already criticised the new chart over concerns that iTunes' dominance in the digital music sector will skew overall sales figures, and therefore chart positions, because certain indie labels still haven't managed to get their artists stocked by the Apple download platform.

But yesterday criticism was based around concerns that that dodgy marketing racket called 'buy-back' will be much easier once download stats are incorporated into the charts. Buy-back, of course, is when a record label buys copies of its own single release to boost its chart position, with the hope that a higher position in the singles chart will aid more profitable album sales. Chart bosses have always frowned upon and endeavoured to prevent buy-back campaigns, but some argue the technique was never widely used because organising a buy-back campaign with physical CDs is both logistically complicated and expensive.

But in the digital domain, some argue, buy-back is much easier to do. A few thousand extra sales can push a single from a Top

20 position up to a Top 10 position. With download tracks retailing at 79p-99p it wouldn't too expensive to do just that.

Some in the independent sector say they are not confident the Official

Chart Company, who compile the chart, have done enough to stop that happening. Guy Holmes, chairman of Gut Records, told the

BBC that he knew of two labels planning on instigating a buy-back campaign this week just to demonstrate to chart bosses how easily it can be done. Holmes: "The people who have instigated the chart have failed dismally in their responsibilities to make and keep our charts secure and to stop people with large amounts of money being able to take advantage of it. It's not a slight problem - it's a huge problem. I know of two different labels who are considering buying records online because they believe it's the only way they can teach the chart people that the security of the chart is no longer there".

However,

Omar Maskatiya, Charts Director at the Official UK Charts Company, said he was confident that the new chart was sufficiently secure, and warned that any label found to instigating a buy-back campaign, for whatever reason, faced being banned from the charts: "We will treat hyping in the digital world in exactly the same way as we do for physical formats. We're pretty confident on the security front and obviously haven't taken that issue lightly."

The OCC say that they will be tracking for any bulk purchase of individual tracks on one credit card and mobile phone, adding that they have been running the download only chart for eight months now and know how to deal with download platform data.

All in all, it will be interesting to see how things work out this weekend.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy