Apr 20, 2005 • 3 min read

Court orders ISPs to identify 33 suspected downloaders for BPI

A High Court order means internet service providers must reveal the names and addresses of 33 suspected file-sharers, whom the BPI plans to sue, with Geoff Taylor warning users they are not anonymous.

Another good day in court for you music industry types. The BPI has secured access to the names of 33 individuals that it reckons have been illegally uploading music files onto P2P networks like Kazaa. The ruling at the High Court in London means internet service providers will now have to reveal the names and addresses of those individuals so the record labels can being legal action against them.

As reported more times than I care to mention, every time the BPI wants to sue a suspected downloader for copyright violation they must go through a two stage process. Internet tracking technology will only reveal the ?IP address' of the suspected downloader and only the internet service providers can link that information to an actual name and address. The music industry must demonstrate to the courts that they have sufficient evidence against an individual before the ISP can be forced to hand over that information. Then the industry can begin legal proceedings against the individuals themselves. It is the first stage of that process the BPI has fulfilled in their latest legal assault on individual downloaders.

Welcoming the latest High Court decision, BPI general counsel Geoff Taylor told CMU's Stop The Evils Of Downloading Editor: "This court order should remind every user of a peer-to-peer filesharing service in Britain that they are not anonymous. We are continuing to collect evidence every day against people who are still uploading music illegally, despite all the warnings we have given. If you want to avoid the risk of court action, stop filesharing and buy music legally.?

Elsewhere in downloading news, the BPI has revealed details of the 31 people it targeted in its last round of anti-downloading litigation ? whose identities were revealed to the record labels after a previous High Court ruling. Stats fans will like to know that of the new cases two come from Northern Ireland, three from Scotland, two from Wales and the rest from England. Eleven are from London and the South East, five are from the West Country, two from the Midlands, five from Yorkshire and the North West and one from Norfolk. Presumably the internet hasn't reached the North East yet.

Most fun of all is the news that a number of those being targeted are parents whose children have been using their computers for some P2P. On that Mr Taylor continued: "Parents may teach their children that it's good to share. But kids using these so-called "filesharing" services are not "sharing", they are distributing music all over the world. Unless they have permission from the record company concerned, this is against the law and could end up costing a family thousands. The risks of allowing children unsupervised access to the internet are well-known. To that long list should now be added the very real possibility of legal action if music is uploaded to the internet illegally. The safest thing that parents can do is check their computer regularly and disable any filesharing software. If children want to buy music online, there are plenty of legal music stores that are safe to use".

While revealing all those stats, the BPI also revealed the results of a survey carried out by research company TNS which reckons that in the last two years the people downloading music have spent £654 million less on recorded music because of the P2P phenomenon. Shocking. Of course most of these ?money lost to downloading' surveys tend to be a bit dubious when you look at the stats more closely, but even if we assume P2P-using music fans are sitting on a cash pile of £654 million what do we think they've been spending it on ? I'd guess gig tickets and ringtones. Less money lost to the music industry, more money lost to the record labels.

On the up side though, for the record labels anyway, is the news that there seems to be an increasing awareness among music fans that downloading music for free from P2P is wrong. In the same TNS survey most of the 18% of the UK population who regularly download say they use legal download platforms, while of those not yet downloading 84.3% say they would never consider filesharing illegal. Of course all that really tells us is that the general population now know that when surveyed about downloading the correct answer is ?I'd never use a P2P network?, though that's a good start I suppose.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy