Jun 22, 2009 • 5 min read

Cowell: Sorry about Boyle and crying kids, Brookstein can fuck off

Simon Cowell admits mistakes were made in handling Susan Boyle's rise to fame, but says former contestants who complain after losing have no sympathy from him.

In a long piece for the Daily Mail this weekend, music mogul Simon Cowell has admitted mistakes were made by him and the 'Britain's Got Talent' producers in the handling of Susan Boyle's meteoric rise to fame. He also admits the show might need to find a better way of handling young contestants in a bid to avoid the on-screen tears. But when it comes to former finalists of his telly talent shows whining when they don't quite hit the big time post-win - well, he's got no time for whiners.

With Boyle pulling out of several nights on the 'BGT' post-series tour, and more reports of erratic behaviour back stage and at her hotel, Cowell was defending his involvement in the showtune warbler's life since she became an overnight internet sensation. He wrote: "After she sang , I thought she had come over well, but not sensationally. I certainly didn't think: 'Here comes a phenomenon who is going to become the most famous woman in the world, I wonder if she can mentally cope with it?' I thought she looked a bit eccentric and certainly a character, but that was all".

But once Boyle was global news, Cowell admits, he and 'BGT' bosses probably could have done things better. He continued: "I'm the first to hold my hands up and admit I've made mistakes. Looking back on it all, it has become clear to me that we didn't handle the situation with Susan as well as we could have".

He says that once it became clear Boyle was finding the competition stressful he insisted she have a close friend with her throughout the proceedings, and for a time that seemed to work. He continues: " she was nervous, yes, but no more nervous than Paul Potts had been before his live final two years previously. She understood the significance of the night. Then, during the final show, at the crucial point when the dance group Diversity won, I looked over at her face and thought: 'Christ, she doesn't know how to deal with not winning'. It was a bad moment. Afterwards, I went over and gave her a hug and tried to reassure her. 'Susan,' I said, 'my offer to record an album with you still stands'. And we agreed that we would work together; that it wasn't the end of the road for her. After that, I left the studio. I remember having a drink that night and trying to relax, but still feeling a bit strange. Something just didn't feel right. And sure enough, it wasn't".

But, while lessons can probably be learned, he says, he thinks Boyle is still better off now than had she not done the show, adding that both she and her family have said as much to him directly since the TV show's final aired, and since and despite the whole Priory thing.

As for the weeping kids on the show, Cowell, like fellow 'BGT' judge Piers Morgan, reckons children should still be allowed to take part, even though two broke down on live TV during the semi-finals and final of this year's series, one - eleven year old Aidan David - because of Cowell's harsh critique.

Calling that incident "my biggest regret of this year" he writes: "I made him cry by describing his performance as lacklustre compared to his appearance the night before, and that made me feel worse than anything else. It was a huge, huge mistake. It almost ruined the whole evening for everybody. Looking back, I know I could have been kinder. In the heat of the moment, I had treated him as I would an adult, forgetting that he was only an 11-year-old child with a dream. I apologised to him afterwards, but it didn't make me feel any better about it. Moral of the story? I don't always get it right".

He continued: "We have to go through a ton of regulatory bodies and red tape to get to appear. It would be far easier not to have them, but I like having youngsters on the show. Why shouldn't they have a chance to show off a talent if they've got one? And win or lose, I want it to be a fun experience for them. We take as many precautions as we can. They have minders or their parents with them at all times, and we take great care of them, too. Yes, on stage things can go wrong, as it can with any live broadcast. I suppose we could have pre-recorded the 'Britain's Got Talent' final, then edited the whole sequence to cut out the crying, but that feels like censorship to me and would open up accusations of hiding the truth from the public".

So, so far, so reasonable. What's going on Cowell? I know, let's ask him what he thinks about original 'X-Factor' winner Steve Brookstein writing a tell all book about his experience of winning the show, in which he will accuse Cowell of caring little about his talent show winners, quickly cutting them off as soon as it's clear they are not going to replicate Will Young/Leona Lewis level record sales for his SyCo record company. And what does he think of all the other less successful 'Idol'/'X-Factor'/'BGT' finalists, who often give press interviews saying similar things once the dream has crumbled?

Cowell: "Steve is not a happy bunny. He never was. He is just a bitter man who the public never warmed to. Steve proved to me that just because you have a winner, it does not always mean that you have a star. Then there's Journey South. They came to us in debt and were at the point of totally giving up on the music business. Even though they didn't win, I did everything I could to help them once the show was over. We released an album. They also did a tour on the back of it and they made hundreds of thousands of pounds. Yet, now, they are complaining that I treated them unfairly. The way I see it, we put them in front of millions of people and gave them an opportunity to make some money in the process. Anyone who is signed to my label is given a fair shot, but it's not a guarantee of enduring riches. It never is in any branch of showbusiness. Sometimes you make a commercial decision not to continue a relationship with an artist. That's how it works".

He concludes: "From the way some of the contestants go on, you would think they had been locked up and tortured instead of voluntarily taking part in a televised talent show. Win or lose, I don't make any false promises about them earning untold millions and neither do I give people a bad deal. I don't mind being cast as the 'bad guy', it goes with the territory, but I do believe I am fair in business. Don't believe me? Here's a fact: there are at least 25 people in this country alone who have made hundreds of thousands of pounds, or who have become multi-millionaires, after appearing on my shows. You don't hear them complaining. Yet a few ungrateful whingers still have the nerve to complain that they 'only' made £500,000 out of the process - for six weeks of work. If the acts who have appeared on my show have been unable or unwilling to capitalise properly on their prime-time exposure, just do what most normal people do - get a job".

So that's you told Brookstein. You can read the full Cowell Mail article here.

Talking of the Daily Mail - not that this is anything to do with music, but it's funny - everyone's favourite tabloid asked a particularly loaded question on the poll section of its website on Friday. In response to a story that NHS guidelines had recommended that GPs treat patients from the travelling community as fast as possible - presumably so they are treated before they move on (or are forced to move on) - the Mail asked its readers "should the NHS let gipsies jump the queues". Assuming the aim of the survey was to get a stat along the lines of "Mail readers outraged at NHS's gipsy queue jumping", the Twitter community got into action with tweeters encouraging their friends to go and vote "yes" in the Mail's survey to skew the stats. The result of that action led to the amusing survey result seen in the screen grab on this Media Guardian blog post.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy