Sep 25, 2009 • 1 min read

Cut download prices to pennies?

Producer Sandy Pearlman has proposed cutting download prices to five cents a track, a model Russian service AllofMP3 once used, to win over young consumers.

I often wonder whether the music business might not benefit from slashing the price of downloads from the usual 79p per track to 10p. Given the cost of actually delivering a download is negligible (providing credit card firms allow fraction-of-a-penny commissions), such a price cut might have benefits if it persuaded more than eight times as many people to download each track. It would be a big risk for the record companies to take that step, but it might just provide the big boost the legit digital sector possibly needs. Or it might bankrupt the record industry as we know it.

Anyway, this very thing has been discussed at a music business conference in Canada this week. And, according to Digital Music News, there were several people advocating such a business model. Legendary producer Sandy Pearlman, in particular, proposed a five-cent per track system, telling the Transmission conference: "I first proposed this three and a half years ago. If it had been implemented, labels would have already made $23 billion".

I'm not sure what evidence Pearlman has for that claim, but the logic is that when the record industry is set on a 99 cent per track model, while young music consumers reckon zero cents is a good model, music firms aren't going to turn the kids into customers without a serious rethink. And for Pearlman five cents is the optimum figure. "Ten cents, they notice", he argues, "five cents, they'll pay".

As DMN's Paul Resnikoff points out, Pearlman's proposals echo the popular model utilised by rogue Russian download service AllofMP3.com back in the day. Although forced out of business because of their dodgy (or non-existant) licensing of the music they sold, perhaps the basic concept of the Russian service was a good one. Resnikoff: "This idea was previously implemented with some success - by rogue Russian startup AllofMP3.com. AllofMP3 claimed loophole compliance with lax Russian copyright law, and was ultimately torpedoed by an enraged recorded industry. But somewhere beneath the rubble, the idea is still alive".

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy