With an increasing number of artists looking at investment options other than the traditional record label deal, and with many labels having less to invest anyways, a big question for the artist management community these days is this: are there alternative sources of investment for artists looking to cover the costs of recording and promoting a new album, or launching an entire career?
The Dubai SoundCity convention posed this very question yesterday, with a tentative "yes" being the answer provided, though I think all involved would agree it is still early days for non-traditional music investment.
First up to debate the issue was Brian Message, a partner in London-based ATC Management, chair of the UK Music Managers' Forum and increasingly the British management community's most vocal player. Admitting that until as recently as five years ago his company operated to a traditional model - with investment in his artists coming exclusively from record companies and music publishers, while his agency charged its twenty percent fee - he said that in more recent years things had changed.
"Whether we're working with new bands who are yet to get label interest, or more established artists who have been dropped by their label, or artists who just want more control over their copyrights, we have been looking into ways to raise funding other than doing a traditional record deal. It's not easy - even when you have a good track record in the business like we do. But when we believe an artist still has the potential to be a commercial success, we'll do our best to find the money to make it happen".
Sometimes ATC put their own money into new talent, though Message has also been busy forming partnerships, both with wealthy individuals, and corporate partners like the MAMA Group, in a bid to raise development funding. "We see our bands as businesses, and demonstrate to potential investors how that business can bring in a return on their investment. By providing a clear business plan, and capitalising on an investors' trust in us as the experts, there are many deals to be done".
Another manager who knows about such deals is Jon O'Mahony, who as manager of folky indie duo Honey Ryder has raised nearing £300,000 through selling shares to individual investors. "The band decided early on they didn't want to do a traditional record deal", Jon explains, "so we looked at alternative routes to raise the £350K we reckoned we needed to properly launch the band. We sold 100 shares in the band at £3500 a time, with each investor getting a half percent of revenues. The copyrights stay with the artist".
Although Mahony admits that this route requires a lengthy business plan to be written, he says there was definite interest for the band's investment opportunity once said plan was completed. "When you apply the UK government's EIF tax relief for investing in new businesses, this wasn't a huge investment, and while there are risks, we have found numerous individuals interested in participating. Some see the potential for a return, others simply like the idea of having a stake in a band".
But if courting investors, whether large or small, doesn't sound like your cup of tea, are there any other routes to seed funding? Government perhaps? "We have provided funding to managers looking to position there new artists so they can take a step to the next level", revealed Iain Bennett from the North West Development Agency, a supporter of Dubai SoundCity's sister event Liverpool SoundCity. "Various government funding initiatives can aid new artists, normally providing money for specific small projects. My advice if you are going that route? Before you make an application, understand the motivations behind the government fund you are trying to tap into. My agency is about regional economic growth - simple creative innovation, which may work with the Arts Council, won't impress us - we'd need to see how the local economy can benefit from your proposal.
I think its fair to say that, despite the seismic change that has occurred in the music industry in the last ten years, the majority of new talent investment still comes from the record labels and publishers. But, as Message, O'Mahoney and Bennett demonstrated in Dubai yesterday, there are other emerging investment options which could provide all artists with genuinely alternative funding models in the near future.