Oct 9, 2009 • 4 min read

Ek speaks as Spotify hits first birthday

Spotify CEO Daniel Ek marks the service's first anniversary by defending its model, revealing ad revenues have passed millions of euros a month.

A year ago this week, Spotify was first made available to the public, and ever since it's been a major part of any discussion about the future of the music industry. Well, it might have taken a couple of months to come to industry-wide attention, though obviously we reported on it straight away. Finger on the pulse and all that.

Writing on the company's blog to mark the first anniversary this week, CEO Daniel Ek said: "Spotify has a long way to go but continued support from the music industry in the face of a recession and rampant piracy has made the difference and I feel that we are set up to succeed with this kind of willingness to innovate and try new things from the music industry... together we can do even better things".

He added: "It's been an interesting year within the music industry, with many insiders questioning whether Spotify's model is a sustainable one. Meanwhile, it's been amazing to see just how our users have taken Spotify to their hearts".

Having bigged up the music industry, he then took a shot at those in the music business who have been busy speculating about Spotify's finances, its precise business model and its prospects for future success. Now you'd never find us doing that.

Insisting it's just far too soon to be going all doom and gloom on the Spotify model, he continued: "The notion of overnight success is very misleading and actually rather harmful to any hope for long term and sustainable growth in this industry. Yet this is unfortunately something the music industry as a whole is particularly good at, expecting business models to be proven within months of inception. The truth is that even the most successful digital business to date, iTunes, missed its revenue targets in its first year by 30%, and label executives were far from convinced that this was the future. We are in this for the longhaul. We aren't interested in just trying to hype the company and then 'flipping it'".Ek remains quite tight lipped on Spotify deals and monies, as you'd expect him to. He did reveal, however, that ad revenues had now passed "millions of Euros per month", and said that Spotify was already 7Digital's biggest download affiliate, even though he admitted the sell-through dimension on his player, whereby users can click through to buy tracks they like as an MP3 from 7Digital, was a bit rubbish. In fact, he estimated that 80% of users weren't even aware of the ability to purchase tracks directly through the player.

Returning to the music industry, and despite his initial praise for their support of Spotify, he had one big criticism which, he said, was stopping the music business from properly capitalising on the potential of digital - that being their continued obsession with per-click royalties rather than profit share deals. If record labels and publishers would approach digital with a different mindset, he reckons, music could become a "$40-50 billion industry and stronger than it ever has ". But that won't happen, he mused, while labels continue to try to "squeeze as much as possible out of every single transaction".

Fascination in the specifics of Spotify's business model remains, more than ever really given that Ek's blog comments on the need for further change in the music sector suggests that he recognises the deals his company is currently tied to won't add up long term.

Trying to guess what's at play, The Guardian's Technology Editor Charles Arthur yesterday pawed over the available information on Spotify stats and costs, with help from the founder of Spotify rival We7, Steve Purdham.

It turned into quite a major exercise, not least because Arthur's original calculations missed off record label royalty payments (focusing on PRS payments). As the journalist's article changed as the afternoon developed it became clear it was almost impossible to work out what sums of money Spotify is currently spending and, possibly, losing. Not least because chances are the digital service has done special deals with the labels and PRS and isn't paying industry standard rates.

However, Purdham's input providing some interesting extra insights. He pointed out that while some - us on occasion - say that Spotify etc can only ultimately work on a subscription model, PRS costs go up when music is provided to paying subscribers rather than those using the ad-funded free service. So much so his conclusion is this: "The fact is that if you can't make it work with ads, then subscriptions won't cover the costs. Subscriptions aren't a silver bullet".

He added: "By going for scale, Spotify creates the problem that the cost base for the music is so high. The costs make the freemium model, pushing people to subscriptions, hard to handle. The model that Spotify's shown in the public domain will need significant investment. If they've just raised $50m then before they go to the US, that $50m has been spoken for across six or seven months".

Interesting stuff. All of which possibly proves us doom and gloom cynics right - and adds credence to Ek's blog comments. The record companies are starting to see their digital revenues grow significantly, thanks in part to the large upfront payments new digital services pay, and to the success of things like iTunes and, albeit to a lesser extent, YouTube and MySpace. But the fact is quite a bit of that money is coming from the venture capital funds of start-up services, rather than sustainable income like ad revenues and subscription fees.

Venture capital money is going to run out, so, unless they genuinely believe that they can make millions in ad sales by setting up their own ad-funded content platforms, those record companies, and where relevant collecting societies, should probably be both listening and responding to Ek et al. Digital music services - especially those which are streaming based - are never going to be able to pay per-stream royalties long term, in much the same way many commercial radio stations don't pay per-play royalties either.

I suspect deep down most labels and collecting societies know this, and are just adopting a 'get as much as we can in the short term' approach at the moment, in a bid to improve this year's bottom line. But that might be a dangerously short-termist approach. If per-play royalty systems are never going to work, and are just proving to be a restrictive barrier to innovation, perhaps the time has come to scrap em and get on with the future.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy