Jun 3, 2009 • 2 min read

eMusic chief defends Sony deal and new prices

eMusic chief Danny Stein defends a new subscription pricing structure alongside its Sony Music deal, saying indie labels had long asked for higher per-track rates.

There was a mixed response to yesterday's news that the previously indie-label focused download service eMusic had done a deal with Sony Music, though that was partly because a new pricing structure was sneaked in at the same time. With eMusic members pay a monthly subscription which enables them to download a set number of tracks from the service's catalogue each month. The company announced on Monday that subscription rates were going up or, in most cases, the number of tracks available under each subscription package was going down, so that the per-track rate would increase.

Although eMusic has to date been an indies only service more out of necessity than anything else - it has been DRM-free since the word go, which ruled out the involvement of the major record companies for years - some of the download firm's customers were attracted by the staunchly independent anti-corporate nature of their proposition. Nevertheless, even the most anti-corporate music fan will often include a number of major-signed artists on their favourites list, so the inclusion of music from Sony's two year old plus catalogue would presumably be welcomed by many of the eMusic faithful.

But not, some in the blogosphere argue, if the arrival of Sony has forced the price change. eMusic argue that the rate change is not a direct result of their Sony deal, and point out that their subscription charges have changed before, and that a number of their indie label partners have been urging them to increase the per-track rates for sometime.

Indeed some of those indie partners, most notably US rock indie Victory, withdrew from eMusic altogether because they considered the per-track rates to be too low. But that doesn't stop some from believing it was really Sony-led demands that actually caused the change in subscription packages and, depending on your viewpoint, that poses the question "does the arrival of Sony music justify the price increase" and/or "why did it take a major label to make eMusic do what the indies had been requested for years?"

Asked about all this by Digital Music News, eMusic chief Danny Stein again stressed that "independent labels have been asking us to change pricing for a long time", though admitted that the Sony deal had provided a useful "catalysing event" to enable the price shift. On why his company was now courting the majors, despite eMusic's previous indie credentials, he added: "For a long time we hoped that we could broaden our appeal - and many of our users complained that we didn't have enough music".

He concluded by saying that, while the Sony deal might mean more mainstream music starts to appear on his service, eMusic will still differentiate itself from its competitors in the way it editorialises its catalogue: "Britney Spears might be there, but we can write and contextualise it. We would like to carry all music, and we will contextualise it with the same voice".

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy