Part of me thinks we should be past the era when research firms pump out stats that show file-sharing aids music sales, while the record industry counters with data that proves the opposite. That's why I've been sitting on this statement for over a week, but feel I need to report on it, just for a sense of closure.
The International Federation Of The Phonographic Industry recently issued a statement countering that previously reported report from research people Demos, published earlier this month, which once again suggested that those who access illegal sources of music buy more music products as a result.
In their response, the globally focused trade body for record label types said: " findings do not prove that illegal file-sharing boosts music sales. They only reflect that there is an overlap between those people who download music illegally and those who purchase music. This is not an original finding and it is consistent with the typical profile of many music fans who today acquire music from different sources, some legitimate and some not".
They go onto argue that "the damaging impact of illegal file-sharing is borne out by nearly all other third party research", which isn't totally true - I think the number of reports that say file-sharing encourages music sales are probably about equal to those that say the opposite.
And the report the IFPI then relies on is one that I think they themselves commissioned, which is cheating a little. Nevertheless, they say: "A study by Jupiter Research in 2007 found that 'online music piracy is the single largest factor impacting lost music spend'. Online music piracy will cost the UK music industry £1.6 billion between 2001 and 2012. According to the research by Jupiter, by the end of 2006, online music piracy resulted in a total of £375.8 million of foregone spend. A further £1.2 billion will be foregone by 2012".
To be fair, they do then cite other independent research that also backs their claim. But I still stand by my theory - backed up by no research whatsoever - that file-sharing does stop some people from buying music, while others use it as a free preview service before buying, but that either way, long term, the music industry (including the record industry) will find a way to survive despite the plethora of free music on the net, in much the same way it managed to disprove its own 80s mantra that "home taping is killing music" by having its most profitable period ever in the early 90s.