Channel Five has welcomed a decision last week by BBC regulator the BBC Trust to ask for more information about the so called Project Canvas before approving the Corporation's involvement in it.
Project Canvas is a joint venture between the BBC, ITV and BT, and is all about providing TV-over-the-internet services that plug directly into a television via a set top box, rather than being accessed via a PC - the on-demand component of the BT Vision service falls into that category.
This project is fundamentally different to the previously reported and now defunct Project Kangaroo, which saw the Beeb's commercial division collaborating with ITV and Channel 4 with a view to launching a joint TV-on-demand platform (it failed because the Competition Commission considered the alliance of the three major broadcasters, two publicly owned, to be anticompetitive).
Project Canvas isn't about launching joint platforms, but rather it aims to develop "technical standards, programme guide standards and editorial oversight systems" that would mean that any electronics maker could make a set top box compatible with Canvas-affiliated TV-over-IP services, and any on-demand service could offer content compatible with Canvas-enabled set top boxes.
The venture, while seemingly admirable, does have its critics - though they are mainly major electronics companies who like the idea of having their own propriety TV-over-IP systems, giving them control over which content owners can connect to consumers via their products. Because that policy worked so well for Sony et al in the digital music domain - oh hang on, it led to Sony completely losing its position in the portable music device market. Still, Sony et al argue that they dislike the Canvas project because it will be too UK-centric, and might introduce standards in TV-over-IP here that then differ from standards everywhere else.
Anyway, it's because of the slightly controversial nature of the BBC/ITV/BT alliance that the Trust has to give its approval before the Corporation can get too involved. They have been considering the proposals for a few months now, but say that they need more information before they can make a decision. BBC Trustee Diane Coyle said last Thursday: "As part of our assessment process we have just completed a comprehensive consultation of the industry. A common theme that emerged was that more information was needed from the BBC Executive about the Canvas proposal. So in the interests of making a robust and independent decision we have asked the Executive to look at the issues that stakeholders have raised and report back to us. The Trust's processes are designed to give us enough flexibility to reach a final conclusion, whilst maintaining a rigorous assessment of the proposals".
While the Trust's request for more information is a little set back for the Project Canvas team, who want the go ahead sooner rather than later, a spokesman for Channel Five has told reporters that they believe the regulator has responded correctly. Not that they have anything against the project, in fact they hope to use any standards to enable them to launch their own widely accessible TV-over-IP service, but, they say, it is important the partners in Canvas get it right, and the Trust has a role in ensuring that.
The fifth channel's rep told reporters: "Five welcomes the constructive and thorough approach the BBC Trust is taking to Project Canvas. The UK's public service broadcasters have an important role in driving Digital Britain and so, as a PSB, Five is supportive of Project Canvas. The delivery of free-to-air content onto the television in the home via broadband will represent a massive step forward for the industry and will transform the viewing experience. It is therefore important that Canvas is a robust proposition in order to meet with the backing of the television industry as a whole".