So one up for the copyright enforcers in the states, but one down (?) in France. The Court Of Appeals in Paris has ordered that the DVD release of Mulholland Drive must be removed from the shops forthwith because the copy-protection software on it violates consumer's privacy rights. That decision follows legal action launched by a French guy who said it was his right to make a VHS copy of a DVD he had bought providing said copy was for private use. The aforementioned copy-protection software prevented him from doing this.
The court's decision could have interesting ramifications for both the film and music industries in France. One consumer rights expert there reckons the ruling means 80% of DVD releases in the country are now equipped with illegal mechanisms, and there is a very strong argument that some of that dodgy PC-killing piracy proof software used on many CD releases these days is illegal for the same reasons. It will be interesting to see how far the ruling extends, and whether it will affect other
European territories.