The German courts have told the record labels they cannot force internet service providers to hand over the identity of suspected downloaders, which comes as quite a blow for the legal fight against illegal file sharing in Germany.
Elsewhere in the world judges have been similarly unwilling to force ISPs to hand over customer information automatically on request (as was the case for a brief time in the US), but have generally insisted ISPs hand over the identities of specific suspects when the case against those individuals is convincingly presented to the courts. Therefore the German courts ruling seems particularly harsh on the labels.
However, experts say new media legislation currently working its way through the German parliament could change the law on the matter and give the labels another opportunity to wrestle the names and addresses of suspected downloaders off the ISPs.