Another clash between the music industry and the wonderful internet service providers - this time in Germany. There have been many mainly unsuccessful attempts by record labels over the years to shift some liability for illegal downloading onto the internet service providers, whose broadband roll out benefited, in the early days at least, by the P2P phenomenon (for a while the only websites that really provided customers with an incentive to invest in broadband were the illegal file sharing services). Most of the recent content owner / ISP clashes have been regarding the identities of suspected downloaders. Record labels tracking illegal file sharing can only identify the IP address of suspects - the ISPs provide the link between IP address and real name and address. The record labels would like the ISPs to hand over this information as a matter of course, but the internet companies have successfully used privacy laws as an excuse not to - which means a record label must take every individual case to court just to secure the actual identities of suspected downloaders.
However, the latest fallout in Germany isn't just about identities. The German Music Author's Society (GEMA) is demanding that 42 internet access providers take steps to block websites that provide access to illegal content, including any that link to eDonkey files. The logic here is that, while the German music industry may not be able to tackle illegal download sites that are based outside Germany (as most of them are), they can make German ISPs prevent their customers from being able to reach the foreign illegal download platforms. The trade body for composers, songwriters and music publishers reckons German copyright law is on its side, and they are threatening to take internet companies who do not comply with their wishes to court.
Opinion is divided on whether German laws do obligate ISPs to block access to such sites, though the consensus is the internet providers will fight any action by GEMA should they go through with their threats and take the matter to court.