Global Radio has been told off by media regulator OfCom for blatantly plugging Apple's iTunes throughout its Big Top 40 chart show.
As previously reported, the Big Top 40 is basically the successor of the old Network Chart/Pepsi Chart/Hit40UK. It was launched earlier this year and airs in the customary Sunday tea time chart slot on over 140 commercial radio stations around the country.
The commercial radio chart has always combined both sales stats and airplay data from radio stations around the country in order to assess what the nation's favourite music might be. However the Big Top 40 is different in that all the sales data comes from one seller - iTunes - and the top ten is entirely based on iTunes download sales.
The idea is that listeners are told the Top 10 as of 4pm at the start of the show, but can influence the final Top 10, which airs between 6pm and 7pm, by going online and downloading their favourite tunes.
The implication of the concept, then, is: "Hey listeners, go and spend some cash with iTunes, and do it now". Such an implication contravenes OfCom rules, which are still pretty strict on there being a divide between editorial and commercial messages. That's not to say Big Top 40 presenters can't mention iTunes at all - the fact they are playing the iTunes Top 10 is a statement of fact - but they shouldn't be pushing listeners to go and spend money with the Apple service. Which they do. Rather a lot.
Following a listener complaint, OfCom investigated the show and ruled yesterday: "We do not consider that the repeated references throughout the programme to iTunes ... served any purpose and therefore appeared gratuitous ... there is insufficient editorial justification for the sheer number and frequency of these references".
Global argue that there is no commercial link between them and the Apple service (more fool them) - iTunes is not a sponsor of the show - and that the frequent mentions of the download platform are there to "remind listeners to interact with the programme and impact the chart itself, on an instantaneous basis". They add that such interaction is, really, no different than any other chart show based wholly or in part on record sales, where the implication is "go buy records to influence this chart".
However that's not a great argument, because no other chart show is entirely linked to one retailer, so while the Radio 1 Chart Show may be implying "hey kids, buy music", they are not specifically telling listeners to go buy that music from HMV, or Amazon, or Tesco. OfCom concluded that the Global Radio produced chart show was "effectively a 'portal' for the purchase of iTunes downloads". Basically Apple are getting three hours of advertising every week. The fact they're not paying for it tells you just how dominant and credible Apple still are in the digital music space.
No one at Global seemed overly impressed with OfCom's ruling, but presumably a memo will circulate around the show's team suggesting they play down the mentioning of iTunes moving forward.