Virgin Media's much ballyhooed (that's a word I'm planning on using with increasing frequency, by the way) unlimited download service may not be as exciting as expected because all but its primary content partner, Universal Music, are yet to sign up.
As previously reported, Virgin announced back in June plans to launch an all-you-can-eat download service bundled in with one of its internet provision packages this Autumn. A bit like Nokia's Comes With Music, but without all the horrible digital rights management, under the new service Virgin customers will be able to download as many MP3s as they want for a monthly subscription fee. Being MP3s, the tracks will work forever, however long a customer keeps their subscription with the ISP.
It's quite a revolutionary offer, and, it seems, a little too revolutionary for many in the record industry. While Universal Music was a partner in the venture from the word go, according to New Media Age both EMI and Sony Music are cautious of the whole big plan, while Warner Music are also yet to sign up.
It seems that without the crippling DRM of Comes With Music, the majors fear that everyone will sign up for a month, download every song ever made to their PC after paying whatever the minimum subscription rate may be, and then bid Virgin and the major labels farewell, no doubt laughing in a very evil way as they go. Or, perhaps more realistically, that the Virgin offer will steal custom away from a-la-carte download stores and streaming-based subscription services like Spotify just as they are starting to build a solid customer base.
Virgin Media tell NMA that they are happy with their ongoing discussions with the record companies regarding their all-you-can-eat music offer, though a record label source told the trade mag that - while the majors do not oppose the principle of Virgin's new service - they are nervous about the deal currently on the table. That possibly means they want the ISP to take more of the risk should users use the new offer to download massive amounts of MP3s in one go (despite Universal research that suggests the average user would only download about 35 tracks a month).
Said source said: "We want to work with Virgin Media as a partner but any deal has to sit comfortably with how we value our assets against how it values its customers. We have to evaluate each deal as it comes in and make sure we're happy with the overall value of the proposition".
Of course, as also previously reported, Virgin is also promising to take a more proactive role in combating illegal file-sharing as part of any deal that enables the all-you-can-eat offer. That promise is presumably viewed as a big fat carrot by the ISP, who also argue that it's only by offering a service as revolutionary as its all-you-can-eat proposition that any crack down on P2P file-sharing will have any positive results.
Whether the majors can be persuaded that the carrot is big enough to accept other terms with which they are not 100% happy - especially given that ISPs like Virgin may now be forced to crack down on file-sharing anyway - remains to be seen. Though, with BSkyB lining up a similar offer, if the labels do eventually follow Universal's lead and sign up there could be some interesting times ahead, for music fans and Virgin's digital music rivals as much as the record industry itself.