Until MySpace get a deal in place with indie label digital rights body Merlin, I suspect every time they launch their enhanced music service in each new territory they'll be subject to a load more bad press.
As previously reported, when MySpace originally launched their MySpace Music platform in the US last year there was a big backlash from the indie label community, who were critical of the Rupert Murdoch-owned social networking company for launching their new music offer without a Merlin deal in place. The lack of said deal means large amounts of indie label music is missing from the service. This despite MySpace co-founder Chris DeWolfe admitting that it was the indie labels who initially embraced MySpace's artist profile community, on which MySpace Music capitialises.
The social networking giant's enhanced music service is backed by all four major record companies, all of whom have a stake in the MySpace Music division. It also carries music from some smaller indie labels and artists via deals with digital aggregators IODA and The Orchard. However, many key independent labels are not part of MySpace Music because of the lack of a Merlin deal.
The independents argue that it is unfair that the majors were offered a stake in MySpace Music in order to get their participation, but no such deal has been offered to the indie sector. They add that, because the majors took up the equity offer, if they enter into a deal with MySpace Music without equity then their music is providing a tangible commercial benefit to their big competitors, while the indie's enjoy no commercial benefit from the majors' involvement.
Given the outrage expressed by indie types when MySpace Music was launched in the US, it is perhaps unsurprising that the Australian indie label community have reacted badly to the arrival of the service down under last week. In a statement issued on Friday, the Australian Independent Record Labels Association said: "In not finalising an equitable deal with the most important independents in the world, including Australia's leading companies such as Shock, Inertia, MGM and Liberation/Mushroom, MySpace Music have shown, as they did with the launch of their US service, scant regard for the value of independent rights".
It continued: "Approximately 30% of Australia's market share is independent. This includes artists like The John Butler Trio, Geoffrey Gurrumul Yunupingu, The Temper Trap, Urthboy, The Herd, Midnight Juggernauts, Bertie Blackman, Adam Brand, Birds Of Tokyo, The Getaway Plan, Nick Cave, Sia, Eddy Current Suppression Ring, The Drones and thousands of others. None of whom are available for streaming on MySpace Music".
Commenting for Merlin, the digital rights body's top man Charles Caldas told CMU: "MySpace Music's ongoing disregard for the value of independent repertoire is underlined again with this Australian MySpace Music launch. For MySpace, which has build its brand on the breadth and diversity of its music, to launch a service without the valuable global independent repertoire Merlin represents is disappointing enough, but to launch without offering the repertoire of any of the major Australian independents shows an enormous arrogance towards the Australian independent community".
He continued: "As a result, Australian consumers are being presented with a significantly inferior offering via this launch, with a gaping hole left by the local and international companies that have been excluded. For MySpace Music Australia to be successful, the artists we and our Australian members represent must be onboard, and their absence will be instrumental in turning the most active music fans away from the service".
Speaking as a key player of the Australian indie label scene, the MD of the Shock Group, Marcus Seal, told CMU: "Whilst MySpace has played a role in providing access to a diverse range of Australian artists' music, it has generated huge advertising revenue without any recompense to those from whom it has profited. Shock has worked with thousands of emerging Australian artists and we're deeply affronted at MySpace's appalling attitude to this most creative sector of the artistic community".
Finally, the chair of the Australian Independent Record Labels Association, Rubber Records owner David Vodicka, hit out at the number of Australian politicians who welcomed the arrival of MySpace Music to the country last week, without noting the lack of Australian independents on there. A number of key political types have even provided personal playlists for MySpace Music to publicise at launch.
Vodicka: "It is extremely disappointing that Australia's leading politicians have provided their tacit endorsement of this new service, without regard to the rights of Australian independent creators and content owners. Small business within the Australian music industry is the big loser here".