Some people really like Creative Commons. Some people really hate them. Of course, most people couldn't care less, because they are essentially a branch of copyright law and, as we all know, the thing about copyright law is that - while it is the very foundation on which the music business is built - it is also very very dull. So kudos to the MusicTank team for creating a very interesting and, at times, entertaining debate at last night's Think Tank event - despite the fact it had the copyright principle of Creative Commons as its theme.
Creative
Commons is a new copyright philosophy which enables creators to make their work available to the public for non-commercial use for free. The people behind the philosophy, which was originally articulated by Stanford University professor Lawrence Lessig, now offer young creatives template legal documents that enable them to formally make aspects of their work copyright free, as well as internet tools with which they can publish their work online.
The movement has caused some controversy in the music business because label and music publishing executives fear that young musicians, eager to get their work in the public domain, may be attracted to Creative Commons and inadvertently give away the rights to their work - rights which, one day, could be valuable.
Voicing those concerns, Emma Pike of British Music Rights, the joint body designed to promote and protect the copyright of songwriters, told the Think Tank: "I don't have a problem with the concept of Creative Commons. However, I am very concerned that the people behind Creative Commons are not giving young artists and songwriters enough information and explaining the long term risks of giving away the copyright on even some of their original works - especially as a Creative Commons licence is irrevocable once issued."
Defending the movement, Paula Le Dieu of the Creative Commons International organisation, and Oxford University's Damian Tambini, who is heading up the UK implementation of the philosophy, said they accepted the industry's concerns and recognised that they might need to review the information they provide to people considering granting a CC licence for their work. However, they stressed that the Creative Commons movement was not attempting to trick creators into giving up their copyright. Rather, they argued, they are aiming to offer the tools that enable those people to promote and share their work, to encourage creative collaboration, and to help increase the value of those creators' future work.
**Neil
Leyton, of independent record label Fading Ways Records**, also talked up the value of Creative Commons in increasing the value of a musician's future work. His company uses Creative Commons as a way of making some of their artist's work available for free. That won the artists a fan base that they would never have reached with conventional marketing channels, and, Leyton argued, it meant more record sales in long term. Those fans appreciated the fact the label issued Creative Common licences with their free music because it meant that they could safely download, share and remix them without the fear some sinister authority like the Recording Industry Association of America would suddenly show up with a copyright violation lawsuit.
Those in the industry might argue that artists and labels are always at liberty to give away music if they so chose, and that they don't need a complicated new branch of copyright law to enable them to do so. However most of those opposing the concept at the MusicTank event were willing to concede they had no problem with the Creative Commons movement providing they were clear and upfront about the future implications of making your music copyright free - in essence the point with which Pike began the debate.
Of course quite how and where Creative Commons should or will educate creatives on the implications of their licences remains to be seen - to be fair, and as Le Dieu pointed out - "it's not really our job to single handedly educate everyone in copyright law". But as MusicTank chairman Keith Harris pointed out, what young creatives might need is more a lesson in reality than copyright law - "one thing that occurs to me,"
Keith pointed out, "is that for some artists there early work is their best work. There is a danger here that artists will give away the copyright on their first album in order to get noticed on the basis they'll earn money on later albums.
But for some bands that first album is really it - and they might be giving away all their future potential income".
More on Creative Commons, if you're interested, at http://www.creativecommons.org/