Oh look at this - this is a fun new angle to the EMI Warner merger story. Now it seems BMG want to buy EMI. Yes, a BMG EMI merger story, we've not had one of those for ages. This is very exciting. I might have to buy a new hat to celebrate.
Back when there were five major record companies - Universal, Sony, BMG, Warner and EMI - the fact the first of those was so much bigger than the other four meant there was frequent speculation two of the smaller majors would merge, with different rumours suggesting different combinations of merging companies, so much so every combination was mooted at one time or another I think. In the end, of course, it was the recorded music divisions of Sony and BMG that merged to create SonyBMG. Though if I remember rightly the merger was a bit of a surprise and was rarely considered the most likely major label merger until it actually happened.
Of course after the big merger BMG owners Bertelsmann slowly started to ease themselves out of the music industry, first selling off their music publishing company (which wasn't part of the SonyBMG deal) to Universal, and then letting Sony buy them out of SonyBMG joint venture. However, they kept the BMG name and a handful of former SonyBMG recording catalogues and, as previously reported, recently launch BMG Rights Management.
The aim of BMG Rights Management seems to be to approach the music industry differently to traditional record and music publishing companies, like that Bertelsmann used to own. From what I can see, that means it will get involved in all kinds of music rights, rather than focusing on, or having separate divisions dealing with, say, recording and/or publishing rights. It also looks like the company plans mainly to either buy up existing catalogues of content, or form business partnerships with artists, songwriters and other rights holders in which it will represent and administrate their IP rights globally, rather than signing and ploughing large sums of money into new talent, and the production of new sound recordings, as is the way of traditional record companies.
Which makes the idea the new BMG company would want to buy EMI seem a little ridiculous - why reject the traditional music company model, and then buy a traditional music company, albeit one that has been radically restructured by the bosses put in by its most recent owners Terra Firma.
But nevertheless, a German magazine called Manager Magazin claims that Bertelsmann is seriously considering attempting some kind of acquisition of some part of the London-based major. Though that might mean buying one or more of EMI's catalogue (recording or publishing) rather than taking over its new artist operation, which would fit more with the BMG Rights Management model as I understand it.
Though why Terra Firma would want to sell off portions of EMI's catalogue I'm not sure, given back catalogue is arguably the company's greatest asset. So unless they were really desperate for cash, I'm not sure any offers to buy this bit or that part of EMI's content archive would be especially well received by the London major or their private equity owners. But who knows?
An EMI rep told Billboard they had not been approached by anyone at Bertelsmann as yet, and Manager Magazin did suggest some kind of EMI archive purchase is just one of a number of possible routes to expansion the all new BMG is considering. So it's probably all pipe dreams and/or idle speculation as yet. Though Manager Magazin says that there are German equity firms talking to Bertelsmann about co-funding its new expansion in the music market.
As previously reported, there have been new rumours of an EMI Warner merger, which would create a third major record company of similar size to those two company's main rivals, Universal and the post-SonyBMG Sony Music. It's not clear whether any such deal, if there were such a thing, would see Warner buy out EMI completely, or whether there'd be a true merger that meant Warner's shareholders would become business partners of Terra Firma in a bigger music enterprise.
If EMI and Warner did merge - and we should stress all talk of merger is so far speculation - it is possible one or the other might have to sell of some of its archive catalogues to satisfy European competition regulators which would certainly provide an opportunity for the all new BMG if it is looking to swell its music rights bank.