ITN news man Alastair Stewart, probably best known these days for fronting ITV's London news programme, has said he thinks the BBC needs to undergo a "Beeching style enquiry" whereby an independent expert would consider which of the Corporation's many ventures really can be justified, and which are really unviable or unnecessary projects kept alive by BBC bosses out of touch with commercial realities. The latter, presumably, would be shut down. If such an enquiry was really to follow in the footsteps of Richard Beeching's controversial 1960s review of Britain's railway network, an awful lot of the Beeb's periphery ventures would be wound down. And if it had the same impact as Beeching, whoever did the review would find themselves being criticised for decades to come.
Stewart was, of course, participating in the debate on the future funding of public service broadcasting. As previously reported, the government's recent 'Digital Britain' report proposed keeping an albeit tiny portion of the licence fee aside to fund public service programming on commercial networks, like local news and kid's shows. The BBC have long objected to any proposals they share some of the licence fee, and have become increasingly vocal on the matter since the government's report of the future of digital media.
Stewart, as a local news presenter in the commercial sector, is not unbiased of course. Speaking to a CBI event in Liverpool last week, according to the Guardian Stewart said: "In extreme circumstances we need unusual solutions and this is just such a circumstance". Noting that commercial broadcasters can no longer afford to commercially fund local news, he added: "At this time, balanced reporting of economic, business and political events, nationally and locally, is more important than ever. The UK cannot afford to leave it to the BBC alone".
He disputed claims by BBC bosses that there is simply no spare licence fee money to go to commercial broadcasters, arguing the Corporation is bloated, with bosses there keeping unnecessary and unviable services alive just because they can. He concluded: "They run more TV and radio channels than you could shake an antenna at. I think they might benefit from a Beeching-style enquiry to explore just how well they are serving the public with the public's money and just how many of those media branchlines are really necessary and viable".