A US judge has indefinitely extended EMI's injunction over slightly controversial American download site Bluebeat.com. These were the guys selling MP3s at a bargain basement 25 cents a time, while providing unlimited on-demand, ad-free, gratis streaming.
They came to wider attention, of course, when Music Ally noticed they were selling and streaming the Beatles catalogue, even though the Fab Four's music is not available via any legit download services as a result of ongoing squabbling between co-owners EMI and Beatles company Apple Corps about how to digitally licence the music.
As you may remember, once the spotlight fell on Bluebeat.com, and EMI's lawyers got their cease and desist stationery out, the company behind the service produced a rather quirky defence. They argued that they had recreated all of the sound recordings they were distributing using a technique called "psycho-acoustic simulation", which was different than simply making a copy of the original song. Therefore, Bluebeat.com owner Hank Risan said, a new copyright existed in the recordings he was selling, and that copyright was owned by him.
It was an optimistic interpretation of copyright law, and a US judge promptly backed EMI's legal claim and ordered Bluebeat.com to stop selling any music owned by the music major. The digital service complied, though initially continued to offer EMI music, including Beatles tunes, via its free on-demand streaming player. The whole site now seems to be down.
The case was due to go to court on Friday, but Judge John F Walter pre-empted that yesterday by issuing a ruling based on evidence already submitted by both sides. He issued a preliminary injunction basically banning Bluebeat.com from selling or streaming EMI music (included reconstructed EMI music), without a licence, forever.
In his ruling, Walter wrote: "Mr Risan fails to provide any details or evidence about the 'technological process' that defendants contend was used to create the 'new' recordings or adequately explain how the 'new' recordings differ in any meaningful way from plaintiffs' recordings".
In an interview with the LA Times, Risan said he was "shocked" by the judge's pre-hearing ruling. He went on to accuse the record companies of foul play, arguing the major labels were fully aware of his company's work, adding that had the case gone to court he had paperwork to prove that was so.
As we commented when this story first broke, Bluebeat.com owners Media Rights Technologies had worked with the major record companies earlier in the decade, mainly on digital rights management solutions, and the firm's streaming radio service had been in operation for years, seemingly without controversy. The company also had a habit of issuing press releases accusing other technology companies, normally the big guys like Apple and Microsoft, of infringing music firm's copyrights through the way they delivered digital content.
All of which made it seem a little odd that this company, in the business of copyright protection, would suddenly start infringing copyrights with its newer a la carte download platform. Also odd was that their existence seemed to come as a surprise to the major record companies.
Nevertheless, when pressed by the LA Times, Risan admits that while he had all sorts of "secret agreements" with the major record companies, he didn't actually have their permission to sell reconstructed versions of their recordings at bargain basement prices. But he stands by his claim that he didn't need it.
Risan: "We worked with EMI directly, and the RIAA, in secret agreements to create these works lawfully. We've been doing so for many, many years. We were about to provide the court with such evidence that EMI knew we had in our possession. We worked with these guys. The evidence wasn't presented because we haven't had a hearing, and the judge made a ruling".
"We worked with all the major labels, all the heads of the major labels, including the RIAA and their parent organisation, the IFPI. We came out with a system in 2003, a secure copy management system, that could not be broken. They tested it and found it to be 100% successful. Upon their testing, they authorised us to make the BlueBeat sound recordings, which we have done over the years, and we agreed to pay them royalties for works that they weren't even entitled to".
"We went and actually got permission at each step of the way. The first step was to show them the technology, which they tested and found to be unbreakable. The second step was they authorised us to make the protected sound recordings. The third part, they totally approved the BlueBeat site - all the major labels and the RIAA".
All of which makes this story stranger and stranger. Though, again, when specifically pressed on the issue by the Times, Risan admits he didn't actually have any permission, from EMI or anyone else, to sell MP3 downloads of his reworked recordings, meaning his case still relies on his belief that the technical process used to create the recordings means no such permission is required.
Risan says he is consulting with his lawyers regarding his options for appeal given Judge Walter's surprise pre-hearing ruling. Meanwhile, you can read the full LA Times interview here.