Mar 24, 2005 • 1 min read

Kazaa owner Sharman Networks defends itself as Australian labels' case closes

Kazaa owner Sharman Networks has argued in closing statements in Sydney that it cannot be held liable for users' copyright infringement, with a ruling expected in several weeks.

Proceedings were drawing to a close this week in an Australian court, as Kazaa owners Sharman Networks reaffirmed their belief that they are innocent in that case brought by the Australian record labels who have sued the company and its directors for copyright infringements committed by around ten million sharers worldwide.

In closing statements at the federal court in Sydney on Friday, the P2P network reiterated their claims that they can not be held liable for the said copyright infringements as they have no means to control how the network users implement the software after it has been downloaded. Whilst the lawyers for Sharman

Networks acknowledge that some Kazaa users engage in illegal copying, they maintain that they cannot be blamed, in the same way that the makers of copiers and video recorders could not be held responsible for illegal copies made using their machines.

Defence lawyer Tony Meagher explained that the music industry's suggestion of putting filters on Kazaa to inhibit the exchange of copyright infringing music files is impossible, pointing to structural difficulties, saying "There is no evidence of the existence of a non-optional filter where a third party determines the content to be filtered and imposes that on users." He also told the court that users were informed that the software should not be used for copyright infringement, saying that "We tell these users in our website and we tell them in our licence that they cannot use this for infringing copyright." The judge questioned whether users would even read the agreement, and the lawyer assured him that users had to confirm that they had read the agreement before downloading the software. Record

Industry lawyer Tony Bannon called the company's claim that it has no control over the software 'completely mind boggling', pointing out that they collect information about users to sell to advertisers, and continue to reward their users with innovations and features that assist in infringement.

The

Record Companies want Sharman networks and its directors declared liable for the infringements, and loss of earnings in a civil case. A decision by Justice Murray Wilcox is expected in several weeks.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy