With the 2022 deal between HYBE’s Ador agency and K-pop girl group NewJeans very much in the spotlight of late - thanks to a New York Times investigation - there have now been a flurry of developments in the various legal battles that have stemmed from that very deal. For the founder and former CEO of Ador, Min Hee-jin, there have been ups and downs.
On Friday she successfully defeated defamation lawsuits filed against her by two other HYBE-owned agencies, Belift Lab and Source Music. They took offence at various comments Min made during a spring 2024 press conference, when she was still running Ador, including that Belift had copied NewJeans when creating rival girl group ILLIT.
However, on the down side, earlier today South Korean police revealed they were referring Min to prosecutors over allegations she was involved in the autumn 2024 bid by NewJeans to terminate their deal with Ador, after she had been pushed out of the CEO job by HYBE. That follows a criminal complaint filed by Ador claiming that Min was guilty of ‘occupational breach of trust’ for her alleged role in NewJeans’ ultimately unsuccessful bid to get out of their deal with the agency.
Meanwhile, also on Friday, the ongoing legal battle between Ador and HYBE on the one side, and Min and ex-NewJeans member Danielle Marsh on the other, was back in court. The session mainly involved bickering over Ador’s failure to provide all the necessary paperwork to identify what losses HYBE incurred by NewJeans’ attempts to quit the agency. Danielle’s side also again complained that the legal battle is taking too long, though the judge said he thought the case was “proceeding diligently”.
Min had a very high profile falling out with HYBE in 2024 leading to her being removed from the top job at Ador in August that year. NewJeans then announced they were quitting the agency in November 2024, subsequently performing a show without Ador’s involvement in March 2025 under the name NJZ.
However, Ador successfully sued the members of NewJeans through the South Korean courts to enforce its deal with the group. All five members ultimately agreed to continue working with the agency, but then in December last year Ador announced it had sacked Marsh and was now suing her, over allegations she and a family member had colluded with Min to try and move NewJeans to a rival agency.
As all that drama was getting underway in spring 2024, Min gave a press conference which is where she formally criticised Belift Lab and Source Music, and publicly accused Belift of copying NewJeans with ILLIT. Both agencies then sued Min for defamation.
But Judge Kim Jin-young last week dismissed both those lawsuits, concluding that Min had simply been expressing opinions during the 2024 press conference, rather than making any statements of fact about the similarities between NewJeans and ILLIT, or about the conduct of the other HYBE agencies.
According to Korea JoongAng Daily, the judge noted that “there had already been online discussion about similarities between ILLIT and NewJeans” before the April 2024 press conference, and therefore Min’s remarks “expressed her opinion as a stakeholder in that existing discussion rather than constituting a public allegation of fact”.
If expressing such opinions could constitute defamation, Kim continued, that could “restrict the free expression of opinions in popular culture and the arts” and “discourage criticism”, which could “hinder the healthy development of the pop culture industry as a whole”.
And while claims of defamation do tend to come up much more frequently in South Korea than in countries like the UK and US, Kim was adamant that “in the field of popular culture and the arts, freedom of expression should be broadly protected”, so long as public statements are not “malicious”.
Both sides actually scored a win on Friday, because Min had countersued Belift, in part over statements it made in a video published in June 2024 that responded to her April press conference.
Again, Kim ruled, statements in the Belift video were simply “expressions of opinion”. Despite both sides having something of a win on Friday, Belift and Source Music have already announced they plan to appeal the dismissal of their respective lawsuits against Min.
In addition to all the lawsuits launched as part of the big dispute between HYBE, Ador, Min and NewJeans, there have also been various criminal complaints filed too. Those generally relate to grievances which, in the UK and US, would also be dealt with by civil lawsuits, but where police and prosecutors might get involved in South Korea.
Indeed, Belift filed a complaint over Min’s comments regarding ILLIT copying NewJeans, and last month police referred the former Ador boss to prosecutors, recommending charges of defamation and obstruction of business. It’s not clear if Judge Kim’s decision in the civil proceedings will impact on that criminal investigation in any way.
HYBE and Ador have also filed criminal complaints against Min. HYBE originally accused Min of ‘occupational breach of trust’ back in April 2024 over allegations she had been plotting to take control of Ador. But in July last year police said they would not be referring that case to prosecutors.
Ador then filed another criminal complaint, also alleging ‘occupational breach of trust’, in January 2025 over the separate allegation Min had coerced NewJeans to quit Ador in November 2024.
That’s the case that has now been handed to prosecutors. Ador also complained about two of its former Vice Presidents, who had been colleagues of Min, over their alleged involvement in urging NewJeans to quit the agency. However, those allegations have not been referred to prosecutors.
Min’s new company Ooak Records has responded to the news that she is being referred to prosecutors yet again following a HYBE complaint. It said “NewJeans’ decision to terminate their contracts was in no way induced by Min exerting influence”. It also criticised the authorities for telling journalists about the case being referred to prosecutors before officially informing Min herself of that development.
In terms of the civil litigation, the case also involving Marsh is the big one. On Friday, Ador’s lawyers agreed to provide additional paperwork needed to quantify what it believes it lost financially by NewJeans trying to quit the agency and putting themselves on hiatus for at least a year. There will be another hearing in that case next month.
Interestingly, none of these ongoing legal disputes were really the focus of the New York Times investigation into Ador’s NewJeans deal. That was more an exposé of how K-pop deals work in general, and how the relationship between K-pop artists and their agencies is different to how artists elsewhere in the world work with their managers and labels.
That said, it’s likely all the legal wrangling in South Korea between HYBE, Ador, Min and NewJeans is why a copy of the contract between Ador and NewJeans ultimately reached NYT journalists. Much to the annoyance of HYBE and the wider K-pop industry.