Jul 17, 2009 • 2 min read

Labels want MCPS to change mechanical royalties rate system

Record labels want MCPS to change how mechanical royalties are calculated to reflect discounts, while PRS warns that linking rates to average retail price would invite abuse.

Whether the new code of conduct will placate PRS For Music's performing rights customers - radio stations, shopping centres, festival promoters etc - in anyway remains to be seen, though the upcoming conflict in the music rights community is probably going to be more focused on the mechanical rights bit of the songs collecting society, so that's good old MCPS.

Music Week earlier this week reported on movements in the record industry to try and force MCPS, the bit of PRS that licences songs to record labels wanting to make so called mechanical copies (so basically the body through which labels pay royalties to the owners of the songs they have released recordings of), to alter its pricing structure.

So called mechanical royalties are set at 8.5% of the 'published price to dealers' of any one album release. The problem, labels argue, is that in recent years pressure from supermarkets and major online retailers to cut wholesale costs means that labels frequently sell stock at less than the PPD. Because such discounts are not reflected in the royalty they must pay to MCPS, that means the label's profit margin is hit. Some label types want the MCPS rate to be altered to reflect that - either by cutting the percentage rate and/or by linking the percentage to the so called 'average retail price', which would reflect any discounts given to retailers on the PPD.

Mike Batt, owner of indie label Dramatico, is one of those calling for such a change. He told Music Week earlier this week: "There has to be a moral rightness to . We can't pay people on a fictitious amount. And I think most labels are in agreement. It strikes a note with anyone who has to make the sums meet".

Needless to say those in the publishing sector do not agree. Acting PRS boss Jeremy Fabinyi, who heads up the MCPS bit of the society, says that linking the mechanical royalty to ARP rather than PPD would be open to abuse. He told the trade mag: "The rates charged were set by an independent Copyright Tribunal. If altered to reflect the Average Retail Price we would have real concerns that unscrupulous record companies could use this to artificially reduce royalties paid to our members".

Some are predicting this matter will become increasingly contentious in the coming year and unless PRS are up for negotiating on the issue the whole thing may have to go back to the Copyright Tribunal, the court that ultimately rules on royalty disputes. Though that, of course, is never desirable, given the legal costs associated with any Tribunal hearing, not to mention the farcical nature of any record labels v music publishers Tribunal dispute, in which you get expensive lawyers in part paid by for by EMI Music, Warner Music, Universal Music and Sony Music squaring up against another set of expensive lawyers in part paid for by, erm, EMI Music Publishing, Warner Chappell Music, Universal Music Publishing and Sony/ATV Music Publishing. Yeah, only in the music business.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy