Apr 27, 2009 • 3 min read

Lammy talks up his Rights Agency idea

Intellectual Property Minister David Lammy promotes a proposed Digital Rights Agency to liaise between content owners and net firms, rejecting the three-strike system.

Following on from a PPL organised event in London last Thursday to discuss the future of good old copyright in this here digital age, the Guardian have been speaking to the ministerial type currently charged with the task of making copyright laws work in the context of the internet, that David Lammy chap.

As previously reported, while the UK's Culture Minister Andy Burnham has done much to woo the music business since taking over the creative industries brief in January 2008, Lammy, who, in his role as Intellectual Property Minister, actually has more control over issues of copyright, has been less keen to pander to the music industry, stressing on numerous occasions in the debate around extending the copyright term for sound recordings that it's the interests of musicians over music companies that are of primary interest to him.

Meanwhile on the big issue in relation to copyright and the internet - proposals that the internet service providers be forced to take a more proactive role in policing piracy - Lammy has previously said he thinks the system preferred by some in the music industry, the so called three-strike system that would see persistent illegal file-sharers cut off, would not be workable. He and his colleague Stephen Carter, Communications Minister and the man behind the recent 'Digital Britain' report, advocate the creation of a Digital Rights Agency to liaise between content owners and net firms. Record companies reckon that's just a distraction to put off making difficult decisions that could lead to copyright infringing users losing their net access.

Referencing to the 1709 Statute Of Anne, arguably the first copyright legislation in the UK, Lammy told the Guardian: "I am not sure there has ever been consensus since 1709 in the family that is copyright, but there have been critical moments in that long history: the birth of the printing press , difference in perception between us in Europe and our US colleagues over book copyright... even the advent of analogue TV brought certain hurdles. But what we have seen in the past three or four years is a massive acceleration in the need to deal with this different frontier. What we are keen to do in the UK is to establish a more shared view on the importance of copyright to our creative and economic future".

Observing that "consumers today are saying, 'we want access to content at a time we want it'", but that "without the creator there is nothing to talk about", he says that one of the problems with copyright is that it is so bloody complicated (I'm paraphrasing slightly) and that in an age when people can and do access content in all sorts of ways, and then move that content between devices and share it with friends, the whole concept needs to be simplified so that the average man of the (virtual) street can access content in simple ways safe in the knowledge they are on the right side of the law.

Lammy: "It would be wrong to suggest that copyright has been largely something in our history that has been in the public domain. Copyright has largely been the domain of lawyers and of creatives, or professionals like teachers. We are moving into an environment where so many people have to be aware of being on the right side of the law, but at the moment accessing those rights is not a straightforward process for the consumer".

Because internet technologies develop so fast, and the nature of content access and distribution changes rapidly with it, Lammy says that excessive new copyright legislation - and in that he's including the three-strike system - is not the solution. Such new laws, he reckons, would quickly become out of date and, as a result, just further complicate things.

Which brings Mr Lammy back to that Digital Rights Agency proposal of Comms man Carter. The agency will "facilitate proper working together" between content owners, net firms and consumers, he says, because, he reckons, "in the end, the solutions are going to be commercial solutions. They are going to be solutions that are about ensuring people pay for content, but the ease of paying is there".

He concludes: "My view is that intellectual property may have been in the past a technical legal issue important to the economy but slightly in the backwaters. It is not going to be that in future. If Britain is to be the knowledge economy that it absolutely has to be in the 21st century, then intellectual property will be centre-stage".

While many in the industry would agree with some of what Lammy says, most major label bosses would probably argue that negotiations between content owners and net firms and digital service providers have been ongoing for years. Talks to create new services have been generally more productive than those looking for ways to combat piracy. In the latter domain the record companies are not convinced further talks - even with the facilitation of some specialised government agency - will result in any consensus between content owners and net providers, and that only new laws will persuade ISPs to take a more hard line approach to tackling illegal file sharing on their networks.

You can read the Guardian interview here.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy