Apr 3, 2009 • 2 min read

Lloyd Webber calls for proper action on filesharing

Andrew Lloyd Webber has urged the House Of Lords to back tougher measures against illegal filesharing, warning Britain's creative industries could collapse without them.

Andrew Lloyd Webber, or Lord Webber for the purposes of this story, was in the House Of Lords yesterday to encourage his fellow lords and ladies to dedicate some brain space to the music industry's endeavours to force the internet service providers to take a more proactive role in combating illegal file sharing.

He said that while the government had set itself the aim of reducing unlawful filesharing by 70-80% over 2-3 years, it was relying on the music and internet industries reaching some kind of voluntary cross-industry agreement, something which is looking less and less likely to happen. The government therefore, Webber argues, needs to start considering new laws to force the net firms into action but, he says, they "would appear to be willing the ends but not the means". He does have something nearing a point there, you know.

Webber told the Lords that Britain's creative industries could collapse if hard line measures to combat file sharing - which may or may not include the controversial three-strike system whereby persistent file sharers are cut off from the net - are not introduced. And, he said, the music industry would be first.

According to the Guardian, he told the Lords: "People have got into the habit of talking glibly about 'content providers' as if they are some sort of optional part of the process. Britain's creative industries are not content providers for broadband. They create the experiences that bring consumers to the internet in the first place, and they can only survive in a safe internet world. The cultural 'free lunch' is not free because film, music and other media cannot be produced, marketed and distributed for free. Investment must be rewarded and performers, composers and authors must be paid".

On the role of ISPs in all this, he continued: "We need to remember that one of the principal reasons for their popularity is that they information and creative content that people want. If internet service providers continually attract people to illegal sites - as they do now - and not to legitimate sources of content, then they are part of the problem, not part of the solution. the internet is a Somalia of unregulated theft and piracy".

On the implication of all this for the music and wider creative industries he continued: "The music business, because of the universal popularity of music, it ease of access and its relatively low bandwidth requirements will be the first to fall, but other cultural industries will surely follow".

As previously reported, despite some tough talking this time last year, in particular by Culture Minister Andy Burnham, the government has so far shied away from introducing new laws to force ISPs to act against illegal file sharing, and Comms Minister Stephen Carter's recent 'Digital Britian' report proposed few such measures. This has led to some predicting that there'll be no real legislative progress in this domain until at least after next year's General Election, rumours which will do little to encourage internet service providers to take on any increased piracy policing role voluntarily.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy