Aug 18, 2009 • 1 min read

Mandelson proposes fines for file-sharers

Business Secretary Peter Mandelson reportedly proposes £50,000 fines and broadband disconnection for persistent file-sharers, a move opposed by some Labour figures.

So, first the government talked tough about combating illegal file-sharing, and implied something nearing the infamous three-strike system may be on their agenda, then they went all cold on the proposals and sidelined them to an after thought in their 'Digital Britain' report.

But now Business Secretary Peter Mandelson is talking about introducing mandatory fines for those who persistently share unlicensed content online, and giving the courts the power to disconnect file-sharers. Rumour had it that Mandy had had a sudden change of opinion on this issue after having dinner with David Geffen - he of Geffen Records - although a spokesperson has denied this.

Mandelson is reportedly pushing for people found guilty of file-sharing to be given a fixed fine of £50,000 and have their broadband connection cut off. Quite how they'd be 'found guilty' - ie whether that relies on content owners taking civil action, or whether he's thinking of some sort of piracy police style government agency - isn't clear. But when challenged with the allegations he'd had a sudden change of heart after being lobbied by Geffen, Mandelson's people insisted that the Business Secretary's opinions were formed as a result of the aforementioned 'DigiBrit' report. Which is an interesting reading of said report.

Mandelson's proposals have not met with immediate support from all in the Labour party though. Former digital enhancement minister Tom Watson put forward the argument often presented by the internet service providers in this debate, arguing: "Challenged by the revolutionary distribution mechanism that is the internet, big publishers are seeing their power and profits diminish. Faced with the choice of accepting this and innovating or, King Canute-style, staying the tide of change, they're choosing the latter option and looking to parliament for help with some sandbags".

He added: "Not only do the sanctions ultimately risk criminalising a large proportion of UK citizens, but they also attach an unbearable burden on an emerging technology that has the power to transform society, with no guarantees at the end that our artists and our culture will get any richer".

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy