A Billboard feature published this week analyses the financial state of EMI, following last week's news that the major label's principle money lender, Citigroup, had knocked back proposals by the music firm's owners Terra Firma to restructure (that is to say cut) EMI's debt commitments.
They note Terra Firma's recent report regarding EMI's performance in the financial year ending 31 Mar this year, in which revenue and profits were up, the latter considerably. EMI's recordings division, where most of the firm's problems are deemed to lie, saw revenues grow 4.6% to £1.095 billion, while profits before deductions were up 217% to £163 million. The major's publishing division saw revenues rise 7.4% to £468 million with profits up 20% to £135 million. All of which means overall EMI Group's revenues were £1.56 billion with profits of £298 million.
So all pretty good really, and definitely an improvement on EMI before Terra Firma's acquisition. But, Billboard points out, you would expect a company brought into private ownership to see some growth shortly after the new management is installed. Especially at EMI, which was widely believed to be suffering from some serious mismanagement prior to Terra Firma's purchase.
More importantly than that, the £298 million in profits is before deductions. Deductions include interest payments to Citigroup, which Billboard reckon could be up to £196 million a year, swallowing up half of EMI's profits, even when the more buoyant EMI Music Publishing is taken into account. Meanwhile, other monies that may have to be discounted from the bottom line profit figure might, Billboard argues, push the company into a loss overall.
The basic gist of Billboard's report, therefore, is that Terra Firma have perhaps achieved more in turning round EMI's fortunes than cynical journalists like me normally admit, but that the major remains weak, not least because of the £2.5 billion in debt commitments its owners saddled it with when they acquired the company.
With time - ie years - things could still be turned around. Had the credit crunch not happened, which would have allowed Citigroup and Terra Firma to sell on EMI's debts and share the risk, time would probably not have been a problem. But in the current credit climate, it's harder to buy time. Which brings us back to our usual conclusion on this - how long will Terra Firma continue to operate with the weight that is EMI around their necks before they decide to cut their losses? Many think not long enough to make EMI a success.