Dec 15, 2009 • 3 min read

More RATM v Cowell ramblings

Simon Cowell has defended the choice of Miley Cyrus's 'The Climb' for Joe McElderry, as the Christmas battle with Rage Against The Machine continues on download charts.

It's always interested me a little that while Simon Cowell is clearly a genius at building up multi-million-generating brands around mediocre pop singers, and was a pioneer when it came to recognising the mega-cash that could be generated by marrying two of the modern eras most popular art forms - pop music and kids TV - the music mogul and leading A&R man isn't very good at the A&R bit of A&R.

That is to say the artist and repertoire bit. Cowell is the king when it comes to spotting the million dollar pop star. But I really don't think he's very good at spotting a good pop song. I hate to say it, but he'd probably be better off consulting fellow judge Louis Walsh or old cohort Pete Waterman on such things.

Hence 'The Climb', the tediously dull Miley Cyrus song that 'X-Factor' winner Joe McElderry has been saddled with for his debut single. However, Cowell has been defending his choice though more against allegations that it was more suitable for McElderry's voice than fellow finalist Olly Murs, therefore giving the winner an advantage.

Cowell told reporters: "Do you know what? A good song is a good song. When we record the songs, we tried them out with five different singers. If they couldn't sing the song, we wouldn't have done it. I thought Olly's version was really, really good... I actually think, if you want my honest opinion, they were both as good as each other with that song. Olly really liked that song and was really comfortable with it".

Anyway, I am bringing this up here in the charts slot because this is meant to be an update on the chart battle between the 'X-Factor' winner's tedious Miley turn and Rage Against The Machine's sweary 'Killing In The Name', which petty Cowell bashers (like various members of CMU staff) are all buying this week in a bid to stop the 'X' machine getting another Christmas number one.

People are following the relative performance of McElderry and RATM on various download platforms. Given the latter is not available as a CD single, it will need to lead the way in the digital charts in order to have a hope of beating the 'X-Factor' winner to the top of the overall singles chart. After an initial lead by RATM, McElderry is now ahead in the iTunes Top 10, though RATM is leading in the Amazon MP3 chart as I write this.

Actually, RATM are at both positions 1 and 3 in the Amazon top 10. This is presumably because Amazon are selling 'Killing In The Name' as both a 79p download and a 29p special offer download. There was much speculation online yesterday that the latter would not count in the final chart calculation, because chart rules insist on a 40p minimum price point, which is presumably why some people have been buying the 79p version.

However, the Official Charts Company confirmed to CMU last night that the 29p downloads from Amazon - of both RATM and Joe McElderry - will count, because the 40p minimum applies to wholesale prices not retail price - ie the price Amazon pay the record label, not the price you pay Amazon. The etailer's 29p special offer downloads are loss leaders, on which Amazon takes an 11p hit, meaning tracks bought this way do count when the chart is calculated. So, go ye and download yourself a bargain. It's up to you whether you go with RATM or 'X-Factor' Joe, we wouldn't want to influence you in any way whatsoever, buy McElderry's version of that tedious piece of shit if you want to.

By the way, and assuming this has been at the centre of everyone's thinking for the last 24 hours, eighteen year old McElderry has confirmed he's a heterosexual virgin. So that's a relief. Here's what he told the Sun: "People say I'm squeaky clean but I don't see things like that. I'm a normal person living the dream. What you see is what you get. I'm straight. I've had girlfriends, but I don't have one right now. I haven't slept with anyone, but I'm a young lad and I'm concentrating on my music. I know I'll probably get offers but, for me, it's all about the singing for now".

All of which is very interesting but, and this is the really important thing to be considering this morning, how am I going to cope with the Adam & Joe 6music radio show going off for a three month sabbatical in the New Year?

PS: Bringing this back to the actual story here, the Official Charts Company tweeted this morning: "Rage Against The Machine starts the week with a 7% lead over Joe McElderry. The race to be Christmas number one is on". So, there's lovely.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy