There was much discussion online yesterday about what impact the new variable pricing system will have on iTunes, given assumptions the record labels will use the new system to hike up the price of the most popular tracks to $1.29. Apple revealed it would introduce variable pricing on single track downloads when it announced it finally had the deals in place to sell DRM-free music from all the majors back in January, though it was an LA Times report this week that that system will go live on 7 Apr that got everyone talking.
The major record companies have long disliked the fact that Apple essentially set the 99 cents (or 79p) per track download pricepoint, which has become the industry standard, without really considering a label's costs or budgets. They've also never liked the lack of flexibility in single track pricing - wanting the option to charge more for those tracks that are in demand, and less for those they are trying to push (usually in a bid to drive sales during one specific week so to engineer a higher chart position).
Apple long resisted calls for variable pricing, arguing that the one-price-for-all model was more user-friendly. I think it's fair to assume the new system was forced onto them by Sony, Warner and especially Universal, who had made their DRM-free catalogues available to pretty much every download store except Apple's market leading iTunes by the end of 2008. Having led the market on the introduction of major-label DRM-free downloads - EMI's DRM-free catalogue, the first to become available, was sold exclusively by iTunes at launch - Apple were increasingly eager to be able to offer all music without the very out-of-fashion digital rights management restrictions. Eager enough to give way on the variable pricing issue.
Some reckon that the labels are shooting themselves in the foot by pushing for the variable pricing model on the market leader download store, and caution major label execs about using the new system to hike up the price of half their catalogue - especially in the current economic climate. Former EMI exec, and now head of digital consultancy TAG Strategic, Ted Cohen, told the LA Times: "This will be a PR nightmare. It is for the music industry what the AIG bonuses are for the insurance industry".
Apple is sure to talk up the fact that under their new system some tracks will be available for the discounted rate of 69 cents, though it remains to be seen what kind of tracks are offered at the lower price. The consensus is that, actually, the vast majority of the iTunes catalogue will stay at 99 cents, but if the 69 cent offers aren't good, and some key tracks rise to $1.29, then there's bound to be some bad press for Apple, which they will almost certainly bounce back onto the music industry. Whether the price change will cause iTunes users to go elsewhere, and whether that means they'll got to rival stores like Amazon MP3, or illegal sources of downloads, or the increasing number of free on-demand streaming services like Spotify, all remains to be seen.