Mar 20, 2009 • 2 min read

Much pessimism at future of commercial radio debate

Speakers at the Guardian's Changing Media Summit were pessimistic about commercial radio, with Enders Analysis predicting its decline, while Absolute Radio's Clive Dickens was more optimistic.

So, there was quite a bit of doom and an extra helping of gloom at the commercial radio session of the Guardian's Changing Media Summit in London town yesterday.

The doomy gloomy feel was initially initiated by Claire Enders of media analysts Enders Analysis who told the conference that advertisers were going off radio as a medium through which to flog their wares, and that as a result the commercial radio sector was ceasing to be commercially viable. The sector would probably be dead within two decades, she implied, saying that outside the BBC only "hobbyist" radio services would exist.

According to the Guardian, Enders told the event: "There is a next generation of people in agencies who are not that keen on radio. There has been a dramatic change in the position of radio in the last ten years, dramatic even though consumption has not been affected as much as newspaper consumption".

Personally I'd have thought that in the on-demand content age where we all skip past TV ads, and mentally (or technically) block out banner ads, short audio ads in among radio programmes and streaming services like Spotify would be among the most effective, but then again effectiveness has never really been high up the agenda of the average fad-obsessed advertising exec. Apart from those who buy advertising in CMU of course, who really know their stuff, obviously.

Enders wasn't the only pessimist in the room. Matt Wells, podcast supremo for the Guardian's website, observed: "We are witnessing the slow death of commercial radio in this country due to a number of factors, the complete failure to grasp the digital nettle. The proposition for consumers of digital TV is completely transformative compared to analogue TV. The same cannot be said of digital radio. And now the worst advertising recession we have ever seen means that commercial radio is on its last legs. If people running commercial radio do not recognise that, we are in worse trouble than I thought".

Will no one say something positive about the future of the commercial radio industry in the UK? Oh look, here's someone who actually works in the industry to be a bit more optimistic. Absolute Radio boss Clive Dickens, while admitting "there are a significant number of radio stations in our business that are not profitable and are not going to make it through the next two years", argued that that didn't mean all radio stations were doomed. He added: "The investment in the relationship you have with the audience will define whether you stay in business. It's not about the sector or structure of business, it's about the audience's relationship with those brands and that content".

Dickens admitted that some big radio firms did need to explore new methods to ensure longevity - in particular expanding content choice and finding revenue streams other than spot advertising sales.

One would have thought the real threat to commercial radio - certainly in terms of the fight for listeners if not advertising spend (but surely the two are linked to an extent) - is Spotify and any other streaming music services that follow its uber-user-friendly music-on-demand model. While there'll always be a place for live radio shows, if Spotify or others operating in their space can incorporate expert-led recommendation services and possibly incorporate some speech content components, large chunks of the average radio station's output will become redundant anywhere that there is internet access.

But look, now I'm being all pessimistic. Hey Mr Radio, think of that as an opportunity not a threat. I mean, despite what Buggles may say, video didn't kill the radio star, surely we can't now let digital and the internet sneak in and knock radio on the head while we're not looking?

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy