Mar 19, 2009 • 2 min read

Music people comment on changes in government funding

Government benefit changes will replace the New Deal For Musicians with Flexible New Deal, prompting varied reactions from industry figures including Alan McGee and Joel Stoker.

From October, the government's New Deal For Musicians scheme, which provides funding for unemployed musicians, will be replaced, along with a number of other New Deal schemes, by a new system called Flexible New Deal.

The New Deal For Musicians was launched in 1999, with the support of Paul McCartney, and offers funding to musicians who had been out of work for more than a year. In exchange for an extra £15.38 a week on their dole money, they have to spend 30 hours a week improving their skills through various approved routes. Musicians who have benefited from it include James Morrison and Jem.

Employment Minister, Tony McNulty, insists similar opportunities will be available under the new system, though some music types aren't so sure. McNulty: "The Flexible New Deal will be tailored to each person's employment and skills needs. This could include support for a specific talent in music so long as it does not limit someone's job search".

Alan McGee, who got his start in the industry from the Conservative-launched Enterprise Allowance Scheme, is among those who are pessimistic about the way the change in the benefits system will affect young people looking to enter the music industry. The government should be doing more, he argues, to encourage musicians and, in particular, music entrepreneurs like him, into the industry. He told BBC 6music: "I think it's a terrible time to be a new band, because record companies are falling to bits. I don't think there is a business model right now. I know a lot of kids who are great entrepreneurs and they would have done well in the eighties and nineties. I came along at a time when it was good to be a music entrepreneur. I would think it's very difficult to be successful at that in this climate. that's not to say that people won't do it".

Not everyone in the industry agrees though. Rifles frontman Joel Stoker points out that government funding schemes have never been a major route into the industry, adding that he never managed to ge his band onto one. He said: "They said 'you need to be signing on for over a year' - or something stupid like that - 'before you're entitled to that' . The government are saying they're helping people and basically you've got to scrounge off them for at least a year before you're even going to get anywhere near that New Deals thing. They turned around and said that if, for instance, you'd been in prison you might be given special treatment. What's that all about? It's a load of rubbish".

Concluding, he said he didn't think any government benefits schemes were that important in the wider scheme of things, saying: "You can always sit indoors and write a song. I'm sure they did that in the 60's. I doubt they had New Deal schemes then and they wrote some of the best music ever".

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy