Nov 12, 2009 • 1 min read

Musician loses $400 billion Bon Jovi lawsuit

Samuel Bartley Steele has lost his lawsuit claiming Bon Jovi's I Love This Town copied his Red Sox tribute, and has appealed the ruling.

US musician Samuel Bartley Steele has lost that previously reported and, I think it's fair to say, always slightly optimistic lawsuit seeking damages of $400 billion from Bon Jovi, Time Warner and Major League Baseball.

As previously reported, Steele claimed that Bon Jovi's song 'I Love This Town' was a clear rip-off of his 2004 tribute to the Boston Red Sox baseball team, '(Man I Really) Love This Team'. He says that he passed copies of his song to Major League Baseball with a view to doing a deal whereby they would use it to promote the sport (if I remember correctly, his plan was to record a version of the song for every team in the league).

Imagine his surprise, then, when the very same baseball league began using Bon Jovi's song to promote the 2007 play-off coverage on Time Warner's TBS cable TV channel. Litigation followed.

Which, all sounds quite reasonable. Apart from the demand for $400 billion in damages, of course. And the fact that Steele lost the case because his own musicologist said that the two songs aren't particularly similar. Oh, and the fact the judge also said that no reasonable jury could ever think that the two songs had anything significant in common with each other.

Despite all this, Steele has now appealed the ruling. Yeah, good luck with that.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy