The man who created the original Napster, Shawn Fanning, has been speaking about his new venture Snocap, an attempt to build a legitimate P2P model which gives consumers the facilities of a Kazaa style file sharing network, but which pays content owners a royalty.
Fanning reckons the key problem with the legal download platforms like iTunes and the new Napster is that, despite their large catalogues of tracks, they do not offer anywhere near the same amount and range of content that the illegal download platforms do. "There's nothing out there offering a content experience with the breadth and content on peer-to-peer thus far. It is clear something is missing."
Fanning's new system identifies every track on a P2P network by "acoustic fingerprinting", so oblivious of where a track comes from or how it is encoded in theory the database can identify a track's name and the content owner. That content owner, providing they are registered with Snocap, can then control what users sharing those files can do with them ñ i.e. whether they can listen to them for free, if so how many times and on what devices.
If it works Fanning could have created that holy grail of the download sector - a legal P2P network that carries large amounts of copyrighted material. However, while the Universal Music Group has already announced it will register its music with Snocap, and new P2P network Mashboxxxx says it plans to use the service, some question if it will be truly successful.
A big problem will be convincing the major P2P networks, like Kazaa and Morpheus, to adopt Snocap - and then to persuade the members of those networks to use the legitimate service rather than finding alternative uncontrolled P2P networks.
Some insiders also say a potential problem will be that, if both the major networks like Kazaa and the major record labels adopt Snocap, then the latter will be admitting that the former has a legitimate use. A key part in the P2P companies' defence against the record labels' accusations that Kazaa et al exist exclusively to aid copyright infringement is that their networks have legitimate uses too - the record labels currently dispute that but, if they sign up to Snocap, would be suggesting otherwise.