Jul 5, 2006 • 2 min read

Neil Tennant and EMI's Tony Wadsworth criticise commercial radio

Neil Tennant calls commercial radio corny and accuses it of blackmailing artists, while EMI's Tony Wadsworth urges radio to take creative chances.

Now I feel bad for dissing the commercial radio sector in yesterday's Top Bit, because it seems like everyone was taking a swipe at commercial radio yesterday. Speaking at the Radio Festival, Pet Shop Boy Neil Tennant said commercial radio was "corny and uninteresting" and accused them of "blackmailing" artists into cooperating with station plans in return for playing their songs.

According to the Guardian, Tennant ranted thus: "You could sometimes think commercial radio lets you down. There is an assumption when you have been making records for 20 years that your records are not as good as they were. Our records have changed and developed, but people who would once A-list something won't any more because they don't think it's cool. People are obsessed with doing things they perceive to be cool. If I was a radio station I'd be thinking, 'what am I contributing ... to creativity, to the community'. I think the assumption that creativity is only going to come from something completely new, or that is a guaranteed hit, is a mistake - that is why a lot of radio stations sound corny and uninteresting. It's difficult to have a relationship with a [commercial local radio] station. The relationship that is developing is a kind of blackmail - that 'if you do a Party in the Park kind of thing we'll A-list your record'. So then you do the Party in the Park kind of thing and then they don't A-list your record because they've lost interest by then. So a mistrust develops."

And then EMI Music boss Tony Wadsworth joined in: "The UK music industry is a very vibrant place and works best when it takes chances... I would say to radio - and I know it's easier to say to the BBC than to commercial radio - if in doubt, take a creative chance because more often than not you'll succeed in that. The artists I've done best out of are the ones that are further out there in terms of creativity. I don't feel particularly let down by radio, but I do think we could all do better, record companies included."

On the upside, BBC boss Mark Thompson, who back in May accused the commercial sector of being too keen to accuse the Beeb as being the cause of its woes, rather than looking at mistakes made within the sector, did use the Radio Festival to admit that the BBC should be working with the commercial stations more in certain areas - in particular in encouraging the take up and development of digital radio. Asked by GCap chief Ralph Bernard if that would mean the BBC would put more money into the cross-industry Digital Radio Development Board, Thompson replied: "We should get together under your chairmanship and look at what a broader remit for the DRDB might consist of. And of course, if that means the DRDB needs more support, then, together with the other members, we would be prepared to look at that and indeed find more money for it."

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy