The New Zealand government has backtracked a little on its controversial three-strike law, though says it remains committed to hardline measures to combat online piracy.
As previously reported, New Zealand were the first country to make the three-strike system law, though the French government are busy pushing similar proposals through its parliament. The law means that if web users continue to knowingly access illegal sources of content online after receiving two, maybe three, warning letters, then their internet service provider will be forced to cut them off.
The proposals have been much discussed in France for over a year now, but seemed to arrive on the New Zealand statute book with relatively little comment - until they were passed that is. Critics of the new law argue that in their rush to get the three-strike system into the recent amendment of the country's Copyright Act, New Zealand ministers failed to give consideration as to how the three-strike system would work, seemingly hoping content owners and net firms could work that out for themselves.
That particularly angered those against the three-strike system, who said that falsely accused web users were in danger of losing their internet access without any proper route of appeal. If the only way those accused of file sharing could stop disconnection was to take their own legal action against a record company's file-sharing order, then that amounted to 'guilty until proven innocent', which is sort of the wrong way round.
As for how many falsely accused web users there might be under the proposed system, Google issued a statement reporting that a high number of the copyright claims issued against its various services - ie orders from labels and studios for content to be removed on copyright grounds - turned out to be false claims for one reason or another. The implication being that when a record company or film studio claim someone is illegally file-sharing, we shouldn't take their word for it.
Content owners and internet service providers in the country have been discussing how they can make the new law work, but New Zealand's biggest tel co TelstraClear last week said it was still concerned about the workability of the whole venture and, as a result, was in no rush to get the system up and running.
With all that in mind, not to mention the online campaign against the new laws that has won support around the world, New Zealand's Commerce Minister Simon Power yesterday said he was putting the new law on hold so that his government could consider the various issues raised by those who oppose the new rules. It seems likely some kind of government agency to police the three-strike system, similar to that outlined as part of the French three-strike proposals, will be needed.
Although in theory it's a temporary postponement of the new system, it is a set back from those in the label and studio community who see more hardline measures against P2P file sharing as important for the future of their industries. And also for those in the music and film industries around the world who saw New Zealand's introduction of the three-strike rule as a good pilot for the system to be used in their lobbying efforts for similar measures elsewhere in the world, including the UK and US.