Dec 10, 2009 • 1 min read

...None in the Netherlands

The Pirate Bay will not appeal a Dutch ruling ordering it to remove links to unlicensed content, with BREIN calling this a mini victory despite the site remaining live.

With all those appeals going on in Sweden, it's perhaps not surprising The Pirate Bay team have decided not to bother appealing that previously reported Dutch court ruling regarding the BitTorrent service. As previously reported, the Dutch music industry's anti-piracy body BREIN successfully sued the Bay for copyright infringement claims earlier this year. Reps for the Bay subsequently picked holes in BREIN's claims, mainly arguing that the site's three founders didn't technically speaking own the service so shouldn't be targeted personally for any infringement the Bay enabled. However, in October another court ruling was issued ordering the Bay to remove any links to unlicensed content on its site, within the Netherlands at least. The court said it would fine the website's owners 3000 euros for every day they failed to comply. The Bay has not complied, or commented really, but BREIN said yesterday that the service had confirmed it had no plan to appeal that ruling. Some wonder if that's because the Bay recently turned off the tracker part of its service, and perhaps folk in charge of the Bay (whoever they are these days) feel that is enough to comply with the Dutch ruling. Though Team Bay did say they were turning off their tracker because it was no longer required for BitTorrent sharing, not for copyright reasons, and anyway the search engine bit of their service, which is still live, is just as liable for infringement claims. The boss of BREIN, Tim Kuik, says the lack of an appeal from the Bay suggest to him that, despite past protestations, the service's founders have realised they have no defence to the infringement claims. The anti-piracy body therefore see the development as a mini victory. Still, the Bay is still live and helping file-sharers all over the Netherlands, and beyond, access unlicensed content. And the men who are now racking up fines of three grand a day? Well, no one knows where they are.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy