A similar squabble to that currently on going between Google and UK songwriter royalty society PRS For Music has kicked off in Germany, after the web firm failed to renew its deal with PRS's German counterparts GEMA with relation to the posting of music videos on YouTube. As a result, so called premium music videos will reportedly be blocked on the YouTube Germany website, in the same way they have been on the UK version.
As previously reported, PRS's licensing deal with YouTube, which covers the 'notes and lyrics' copyrights that exist in any song, is up for renewal, and Google say the collecting society's new demands are too high, ie the ad revenues they are able to generate from YouTube would never cover the royalty fees PRS are demanding.
The dispute is reportedly over a number of issues - include basic royalty rates, how royalties are paid (PRS are pushing for a per-stream royalty rather than lump sum payments like they got last time round) and how data is shared (YouTube want a list of PRS's members so they can pay them direct, PRS want YouTube's viewing stats so they can distribute the money). With the dispute unresolved, Google announced they would block access to music videos in the UK until a deal could be reached, even though PRS were happy for videos to continue to be accessed while licensing talks were ongoing.
As far as I can see, the dispute between the video site and GEMA in Germany is pretty much the same on all levels. Confirming that the way money is paid and stream reports provided, or not, was a key issue in the two organisation's dispute, the German collecting society's CEO, Harold Heker, told reporters yesterday: "Negotiations about the extension of the agreement have failed so far because YouTube is not willing to fulfil GEMA's requests for more transparency the used musical repertoire. YouTube wants the extension on the basis of a flat fee without sufficient information about the used repertoire and the number of streams. GEMA refuses this offer by YouTube because it is impossible to calculate a fair remuneration without the requested information and to pay this remuneration in an adequate way to GEMA's members".
With regards the royalty rate part of the dispute, we have a better idea of what sums of money we're talking about with the GEMA dispute. Google say that the collecting society is offering them a one euro-cent per stream rate in the short term, but with a view to pushing that up to as much as 12 euro-cents per stream long term. Not even the short term solution is attractive to Google. A spokesman for their German office said yesterday: "This 0.01 euro for an interim solution is already too much and actually GEMA demands 0.12 euro per stream for a long-term agreement".
With Google's deals with both PRS and GEMA now faltering, some expect similar problems to occur as deals come up with other collecting societies around Europe. Heker continues: "Other European collection societies are in the same difficult position to succeed with Google/YouTube with their request for proper notifications and a reasonable remuneration. GEMA is ready for this conflict in order to protect the interests of the authors, represented by GEMA. The German authors are upset and criticise YouTube's business methods".