Nov 20, 2026 • 6 min read

Op-ed: IMPALA’s Helen Smith on the action and collaboration needed to tackle streaming fraud

To close International Fraud Awareness Week, IMPALA points to concrete action at the right level and collaboration across the digital music ecosystem to address streaming fraud, with checks and balances built in to improve trust and integrity and protect all genuine artists and labels

Op-ed: IMPALA’s Helen Smith on the action and collaboration needed to tackle streaming fraud

As International Fraud Awareness Week comes to a close, Helen Smith, IMPALA's Executive Chair, reiterates IMPALA's call for tough, coordinated action to tackle streaming manipulation and fraud across the digital music ecosystem.

Throughout the week, we have highlighted the many forms streaming manipulation can take: fake streams, fake artists, fake fans, fake tracks and more. AI and generative AI are adding new dimensions to this challenge, making it easier to create and mass-upload materially AI-generated content.

IMPALA's Digital Music Plan sets out a clear direction: platforms, distributors, rightsholders and trade associations must work together across the value chain, taking coordinated action at the right level.

The consequences of fraud go beyond distorted figures. Streaming manipulation exploits remuneration and recommendation systems, diverts revenues away from legitimate artists and labels, and undermines trust in streaming. Ultimately, it's the integrity of the digital music market that is at stake. 

This is also a question of fair competition: independent music companies often have more limited resources to monitor and respond to fraudulent activity and, as such, they are particularly exposed and can be disproportionately affected. This means it’s essential to take action at the right level to prevent fraud in the first place.

Tackling these challenges requires more than identifying fraudulent activity after the damage has been done. We are partners in the industry-wide Streaming Integrity Initiative (SII) launched earlier this year with IFPI and others and signed the pan-industry voluntary code of best practice, together with other music industry representatives and streaming services a few years ago already, and the current momentum around streaming integrity is a great opportunity to work together to update this. 

IMPALA has a Streaming Manipulation Guidance, fully aligned with our Digital Music Plan, which emphasises coordinated action across the industry and draws attention to the different tactics used and how to detect them, including abnormal data patterns. IMPALA is also involved in different groups with other stakeholders such as AIM’s streaming fraud working group. 

We also support broader industry’s' initiatives such as IFPI’s principles on charts and AI-generated tracks, or the music community’s new labelling programme to distinguish generative AI in sound recordings. Other industry coalitions exist, such as the Music Fights Fraud Alliance for example, which our manipulation guidance refers to, and which are extremely useful to strengthen action against streaming manipulation and fraud.

In our view, action means tougher artist verification, robust KYC and fraud prevention systems, effective detection of fake accounts and artificial streaming, and targeted financial measures that deter persistent offenders such as carriage fees and penalties. Distributors also have a responsibility to verify their clients and content before delivery systems are used.

Our Digital Music Plan also flags that detection and prevention must go hand in hand with proper checks and balances, transparency and clear communication, ensuring legitimate artists and labels have adequate recourse when their repertoire is misidentified or used to disguise fraud. 

But there is of course another dimension that we need to act on: we must establish clear and consistent approaches to AI-generated content to address the growing impact of AI.

AI tools can help improve fraud detection, business efficiencies and boost creative processes. Responsible AI features are being developed for artists and fans. These are welcome where artists and labels are interested in participating.But they also bring new risks, something we frequently see in the press: the mass uploading of materially AI-generated content and manipulation of plays. This is problematic because it helps fraudsters transfer value away from genuine artists and rights owners and increases the climate impact of digital services. 

In October 2026, Deezer reported receiving around 90,000 fully AI-generated tracks every day. It also found that up to 85% of fully AI-generated tracks were fraudulent in 2025, and removed those streams from royalty payments. 

The case of Michael Smith in the US illustrates how AI-generated content and artificial streaming can be combined to manipulate the system as he fraudulently obtained more than $8 million in royalties. How many other fraudsters are gaming the system?  How much revenue has been taken away from genuine artists and rights owners? What is the climate impact?

This point is very important because there is also a clear sustainability dimension to this debate, one which we cannot afford to overlook. Ahead of COP, we pointed to our recommendations on sustainability and encouraged both DSPs and AI services to be transparent about their full climate impact so that this can be measured. This is another area where transparency is essential.

AI has been embraced by the industry for decades and the question is not whether it should have a place in the music ecosystem, but rather under what conditions it can be developed and deployed without undermining the people that make music possible. 

And AI-generated content is of course our focus here. Industry-wide provenance labelling, standard definitions of materially AI-generated content, disclosure of the tools used and proper safeguards are essential. Content generated on an unlicensed tool is infringing and should not enter upload, remuneration and discovery systems, while licensed generative AI content must be properly controlled, labelled and kept distinct from human-created music.

Our digital music plan also highlights that as dealing with fraud can be a competitive issue and resource heavy, proper checks and balances, transparency and clear communication must be in place to ensure that legitimate artists and labels have adequate recourse if their repertoire is used to disguise fraud or misidentified, as IMPALA already called for in our earlier streaming plans. 

No label or artist playing fair should have legitimate repertoire removed or royalties suspended without prompt recourse options and communication channels.

Switching without penalties or losing playlists, or plays, or payment, or other features in the process is also important and we urge all distributors to follow the Digital Distribution Switch Code – developed by AIM’s independent distributor members – which provides best practices to allow labels and artists move their repertoire as smoothly as possible.

As well as tackling fraud, other priorities also have the potential to be transformative for the whole market. Here are some examples from IMPALA’s digital music plan: 

  • Increasing subscription prices, challenging whether it makes sense to continue with free tier in the same way as it works today 
  • Making sure music is included in all price increases, especially relevant where other services are bundled in – there should be no dilution at the expense of music and we ask for more transparency on how value is allocated
  • Querying whether all repertoire delivery obligations should apply in respect of music that is unlikely to be monetised  
  • Measuring our value gaps as an industry, challenging payment models outside of streaming, eg creator economy, moment economy services like TikTok  
  • Adding new payment boosts for new releases, diverse repertoire, changing how the basic revenue allocation model works as recommended in previous plans eg to reward active listening (not all streams are born equal!) 
  • Rejecting payment thresholds for verified artists and changing how money withheld is distributed, ie not just throwing it back into the pot
  • Labels to pay on proper modern terms, review old contracts, labels and distributors to respect WIN Fair Digital Deals declaration
  • Ensuring authenticity, auditability, & transparency of factors affecting preferences & recommendations, eliminating the risk of rightsowner or financial bias
  • Supercharging support for diversity, promoting new releases, emerging artists & diversity in different forms (cultural, EDI factors, language, geography, genre), reporting yearly on concrete actions
  • Tackling dominance, solving the issues raised in the EU’s discoverability report - regulatory intervention may be needed.
  • Resetting the balance between catalogue and new releases

One thing is certain: trust and integrity are ecosystem-wide challenges and there is no single solution to address them. Progress depends on ambition, experimentation and collaboration across the industry, as we say in our Digital music plan. Let's continue working together to protect artists, fans and the integrity of the digital music market."

IMPALA was established in 2000 and now represents over 6000 independent music companies in Europe.

99% of Europe’s music companies are small, micro and medium businesses and self-releasing artists. Known as the independents, they are world leaders in terms of innovation and discovering new music and artists – they produce more than 80% of all new releases and account for 80% of the sector’s jobs.

IMPALA’s mission is to grow the independent music sector sustainably, return more value to artists, promote diversity and entrepreneurship, improve political access, inspire change, and increase access to finance.

IMPALA works on a range of key issues for its members and started a new co-funded work programme as an EU cultural network in 2025. IMPALA runs various award schemes and has a programme aimed at businesses who want to develop a strategic relationship with the European independent sector – Friends of IMPALA.

This year we are celebrating our 25th anniversary programme #WhyIndependentsMatter with a series of interviews Faces of the Independent Sector, as well as reports and other features, see more here.
Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to CMU | the music business explained.
Your link has expired.
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.
Privacy Policy